A Blog by Jonathan Low

 

Dec 30, 2016

The Long Term Job Killer Isn't China, It's Automation

Reality bites. JL

Claire Miller reports in The Upshot:

Analysis attributed roughly 13 percent of manufacturing job losses to trade and the rest to enhanced productivity because of automation.
The first job that Sherry Johnson, 56, lost to automation was at the local newspaper in Marietta, Ga., where she fed paper into the printing machines and laid out pages. Later, she watched machines learn to do her jobs on a factory floor making breathing machines, and in inventory and filing.
“It actually kind of ticked me off because it’s like, How are we supposed to make a living?” she said. She took a computer class at Goodwill, but it was too little too late. “The 20- and 30-year-olds are more up to date on that stuff than we are because we didn’t have that when we were growing up,” said Ms. Johnson, who is now on disability and lives in a housing project in Jefferson City, Tenn.
Donald J. Trump told workers like Ms. Johnson that he would bring back their jobs by clamping down on trade, offshoring and immigration. But economists say the bigger threat to their jobs has been something else: automation.
“Over the long haul, clearly automation’s been much more important — it’s not even close,” said Lawrence Katz, an economics professor at Harvard who studies labor and technological change.
No candidate talked much about automation on the campaign trail. Technology is not as convenient a villain as China or Mexico, there is no clear way to stop it, and many of the technology companies are in the United States and benefit the country in many ways.
Mr. Trump told a group of tech company leaders last Wednesday: “We want you to keep going with the incredible innovation. Anything we can do to help this go along, we’re going to be there for you.”
Andrew F. Puzder, Mr. Trump’s pick for labor secretary and chief executive of CKE Restaurants, extolled the virtues of robot employees over the human kind in an interview with Business Insider in March. “They’re always polite, they always upsell, they never take a vacation, they never show up late, there’s never a slip-and-fall, or an age, sex or race discrimination case,” he said.
Photo
At Eatsa, an automated restaurant chain, customers never interact with a human. Credit Jason Henry for The New York Times
Globalization is clearly responsible for some of the job losses, particularly trade with China during the 2000s, which led to the rapid loss of 2 million to 2.4 million net jobs, according to research by economists including Daron Acemoglu and David Autor of M.I.T.
People who work in parts of the country most affected by imports generally have greater unemployment and reduced income for the rest of their lives, Mr. Autor found in a paper published in January. Still, over time, automation has had a far bigger effect than globalization, and would have eventually eliminated those jobs anyway, he said in an interview. “Some of it is globalization, but a lot of it is we require many fewer workers to do the same amount of work,” he said. “Workers are basically supervisors of machines.”
When Greg Hayes, the chief executive of United Technologies, agreed to invest $16 million in one of its Carrier factories as part of a Trump deal to keep some jobs in Indiana instead of moving them to Mexico, he said the money would go toward automation.
“What that ultimately means is there will be fewer jobs,” he said on CNBC.
Take the steel industry. It lost 400,000 people, 75 percent of its work force, between 1962 and 2005. But its shipments did not decline, according to a study published in the American Economic Review last year. The reason was a new technology called the minimill. Its effect remained strong even after controlling for management practices; job losses in the Midwest; international trade; and unionization rates, found the authors of the study, Allan Collard-Wexler of Duke and Jan De Loecker of Princeton.
Another analysis, from Ball State University, attributed roughly 13 percent of manufacturing job losses to trade and the rest to enhanced productivity because of automation. Apparel making was hit hardest by trade, it said, and computer and electronics manufacturing was hit hardest by technological advances.
Photo
A vacant factory parking lot in Luzerne County, Pa., which flipped from blue to red. Donald J. Trump railed against trade and offshoring, but automation has killed more jobs. Credit Mark Makela for The New York Times
Over time, automation has generally had a happy ending: As it has displaced jobs, it has created new ones. But some experts are beginning to worry that this time could be different. Even as the economy has improved, jobs and wages for a large segment of workers — particularly men without college degrees doing manual labor — have not recovered.
Even in the best case, automation leaves the first generation of workers it displaces in a lurch because they usually don’t have the skills to do new and more complex tasks, Mr. Acemoglu found in a paper published in May.
Robert Stilwell, 35, of Evansville, Ind., is one of them. He did not graduate from high school and worked in factories building parts for tools and cars, wrapping them up and loading them onto trucks. After he was laid off, he got a job as a convenience store cashier, which pays a lot less.
“I used to have a really good job, and I liked the people I worked with — until it got overtaken by a machine, and then I was let go,” he said.
Dennis Kriebel’s last job was as a supervisor at an aluminum extrusion factory, where he had spent a decade punching out parts for cars and tractors. Then, about five years ago, he lost it to a robot.
“Everything we did, you could program a robot to do it,” said Mr. Kriebel, who is 55 and lives in Youngstown, Ohio, the town about which Bruce Springsteen sang, “Seven hundred tons of metal a day/Now sir you tell me the world’s changed.”
Since then, Mr. Kriebel has barely been scraping by doing odd jobs. Many of the new jobs at factories require technical skills, but he doesn’t own a computer and doesn’t want to.
Photo
The Skechers distribution center in Moreno Valley, Calif., is fully automated. Credit Monica Almeida/The New York Times
Labor economists say there are ways to ease the transition for workers whose jobs have been displaced by robots. They include retraining programs, stronger unions, more public-sector jobs, a higher minimum wage, a bigger earned-income tax credit and, for the next generation of workers, more college degrees. The White House released a report on automation and the economy that called for better education from early childhood through adult job transitions and for updating the social safety net with tools like wage insurance. Few are policies that Mr. Trump has said he will pursue.
“Just allowing the private market to automate without any support is a recipe for blaming immigrants and trade and other things, even when it’s the long impact of technology,” said Mr. Katz, who was the Labor Department’s chief economist under President Clinton.
The changes are not just affecting manual labor: Computers are rapidly learning to do some white-collar and service-sector work, too. Existing technology could automate 45 percent of activities people are paid to do, according to a July report by McKinsey. Work that requires creativity, management of people or caregiving is least at risk.
Ms. Johnson in Tennessee said both her favorite and highest-paying job, at $8.65 an hour, was at an animal shelter, caring for puppies.
It was also the least likely to be done by a machine, she said: “I would hope a computer couldn’t do that, unless they like changing dirty papers and giving them love and attention

44 comments:

Unknown said...

Very well researched article. In the IT industry, most of the people are under the impression that automation is going to cause severe damage to their roles, but the automation as the phenomenon is going to impact large part of the society, irrespective of the Industry.

It's time that people wake up to the reality, and start focusing on finding the next best job markets for survival and sustenance.

mickeyarthur said...

Agreed with the fact that technological advancements and automation are some of the top reasons for fewer job opportunities. When last semester I took Law Assignment Help Online and economics assignment help online I have found in it that how drastically machines have replaced human labor.

Isabell Kiral said...

China is a developed country and providing more jobs for its nation and their unemployment ratio is very low, but other countries included USA, are facing this problem. All governments of the World should take a serious action towards unemployment, so that every country can get rid of this issue. Buy Dissertation Online.

Thomas More said...

I do agree that automation is killing job opportunities. But I think there are more opportunities than there ever were. You just have to have a skill that is in demand. I remember I paid a writer quite an amount to Do My Dissertation UK style, all because he had the skill to write a perfect dissertation. I think that’s the way to go – master a skill that is in demand, and you don’t have to worry about automation.

James Herry said...

China is one of the best country in the world.Most of the big industries are developed in china.The unemployment ratio of the china is very low as compare to other countries.Most of the countries are facing this problem.Get the best nursing essay help uk service for the students at an affordable and reasonable price.

thisisemliyblunt said...

Grreat website if you looking for something extra, very quick delivery. Always good service. cushions were all lovely and good quality, arighi bianchi discount code.

thisisemliyblunt said...

Perhaps the earliest thing to think about while going with this choice is taking a gander at the volume and recurrence of bookkeeping services when you want specific monetary assignments done.

elisjohn said...

China is a country which extremely supports and promote sports and extra curricular activities. There are many people and youth actively takes part in football matches and loves this sport. For such chines people there's a good news that UCL Final will be happening live in US but all the chines people can use VPN to watch the live streaming of the match.

thisisemliyblunt said...

That is beyond what you can say for certain destinations! They are my 'go to' for investment funds. Phenomenal Best Discount code site
summer vacation
london travel guide
Emporio Armani
Beach Vacations
Fashion Discount code
Beauty Discount code. The code alows you to purchase what you really wanted at discounted cost.

margotrobbie said...

Indeed I'm totally agree with you that automation is killing job opportunities. But everything have there pros and cons there are more opportunities than there ever were just because of a automation industry. You just have to learn new skill that is in demand. I hire writer from best academic writing services provider, all because she had the skill to do my academic task perfectly. I think that’s the way to go – master a skill that is in demand, and you don’t have to worry about automation and anything else.

Casestudysamples said...

Buy case study helps you write better case studies using the proven formula of communication, sharing and influence. You get a summary of your findings, a time line for each step in the design process, and a starting point to create your report.

Anonymous said...

We are providing finance assignment help to students all over the world. We are one of the top rated finance assignment help websites.

Pay for Assignments said...

let’s admit that without the assistance of professional dissertation help, the goal of writing a vivid and unique dissertation to achieve the desired grades is nearly impossible. No wonders hundreds of Ph.D. students approach payForAssignments.co.uk every week and ask to “do my dissertation UK

Lakeview Boutique Hotel Kirkland said...

Thanks for Sharing Such an amazing Blog post with us, you're doing Great work out there.

infovocher.com said...

Thank you for such a wonderful post

https://bakershomecleaning.com/services/moving-in-out-cleaning-services/ said...

I really enjoy reading your post where I get such useful information.

Anonymous said...

https://rockymountainsnaps.com Thanks for sharing this information!

pubghack122 said...

We have mentioned the two distinct kinds of modes which suggest that you can actually revel in playing PUBG cell each individually and with friends. One can growth the stats and kill quotes by playing with PUBG cell Aimbot.
https://pubgmobilehackapk.info/

https://birdsoasis.com said...

I love this blog. Thank you so much for sharing all this wonderful

golfrange said...

Automation is a major factor in the long-term job market, and it's only getting more powerful. As technology continues to advance, we can expect to see more jobs replaced by automation, which could have a devastating impact on the global economy. It's important to recognize this trend and take steps to ensure that workers are adequately prepared for the future.

Ovais Khan said...

Watch Age of Adaline from anywhere in the world on netflix

Vivian Raddix said...

I really appreciate the insights and tips you provide in your blog posts. Join Our IELTS Coaching in Vadodara and Achieve Your Dream Score.

Anonymous said...

Great post! I really enjoyed reading your thoughts on this topic. Furthermore, if you are looking for a custom Web design and development, you can contact Design Fictives.

nithu said...

I have read your post and i am here to thank you for sharing this post

A virginia beach personal injury attorney is a legal professional who specializes in providing legal representation and assistance to individuals who have been injured due to someone else's negligence or wrongful actions in the Virginia Beach area.

Herbert Matson said...

Your skills and efforts are truly appreciated. Keep up the great work! I wanted to take a moment to let you know that you can also good job same with https://appsleagues.com

Logo Leagues said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Logo Leagues said...

https://cellmartusa.com

darcymarsh said...

A Women's Thermal Fur Collar Hooded Jacket combines warmth and style, featuring a cozy fur collar and a hood for extra comfort during chilly weather. This fashionable outerwear piece effortlessly blends functionality with a touch of luxury for a chic winter wardrobe essential.





shane said...

"Low down" typically refers to providing detailed or inside information on a particular subject, often revealing insights or facts that are not widely known. It can also denote a lowered or depressed emotional state. The term is colloquially used to describe getting the real or hidden facts about a situation, and it may have different interpretations based on context.
virginia statute of limitations personal injury
northern virginia personal injury attorney
abogado de accidentes de semi camiones
bufete de abogados de accidentes de motocicleta

clara dorothy said...

"The Long Term Job Killer Isn't China, It's Automation offers a thought-provoking perspective on the future of employment. By highlighting the role of automation in shaping labor markets, the article challenges conventional narratives about job loss. It emphasizes the importance of addressing the impact of technology on employment in shaping effective policies. A timely and insightful read for anyone interested in understanding the evolving nature of work in the age of automation." New York No-Fault State Divorce

german language said...

Understanding SWWE Architecture:
SWWE architecture revolves around the integration of design principles and technologies that minimize environmental impact while maximizing resource efficiency. In Karachi, where rapid urbanization and population growth exacerbate resource scarcity and environmental degradation, SWWE architecture offers a promising approach to mitigate these challenges.

clara dorothy said...

The article "The Long Term Job Killer Isn't China, It's Automation" explores the changing job market dynamics, highlighting the transformative impact of automation on employment patterns. It challenges conventional narratives about job loss and sparks discussions about the intersection of technology and employment. Desestimar Orden Protección Nueva Jersey

Shashkay said...

In the vibrant tapestry of Pakistan's fashion landscape, Shashkay Sunglasses emerges as a symbol of elegance, innovation, and unparalleled quality. With a commitment to blending timeless design with cutting-edge technology, Shashkay has quickly become a favorite among fashion-forward individuals seeking to elevate their style while protecting their eyes. This blog delves into the captivating world of Shashkay Sunglasses, exploring its unique offerings, commitment to excellence, and influence on the Sunglasses in Pakistan

Vape Star USA said...

I'm grateful for your contribution and look forward to applying the knowledge gained from your response. Once again, thank you for your thoughtful and helpful input just visit: at rechargeable disposable vape

Puff n Pass Smoke & Vape Shop said...

Thanks for sharing i really agree. It is good ! Check out our cool vapes and CBD goodies, handpicked for your enjoyment. Join us at oakland smoke shop

Print Monkey said...

screwfix cardboard boxes offer durable and reliable packaging solutions for various items. With sturdy construction and convenient sizes, they ensure safe and secure transportation and storage.




Alex joo said...

Say goodbye to late nights spent crunching numbers. Our bookkeeping services offer a flexible and scalable solution for businesses of all sizes. We tailor our services to your specific needs and budget, ensuring accurate and timely financial data without the burden of managing it yourself.

Chris Hales said...

Wow, this article really opened my eyes to new possibilities for making money! I appreciate the detailed tips and actionable advice. Can't wait to put them into practice. If anyone else is interested in boosting their income, click here for more insightful articles like this

B plan writer said...

Nice post keep it up your work by the way just visit our website immigration business plan writer

visaconsultant said...

With a focus on sustainable urban development, Packages Limited has undertaken various residential and commercial projects characterized by modern design and eco-friendly practices. Their integration of cutting-edge technologies and emphasis on customer satisfaction have earned them accolades in the construction sector.

Shashkay said...

Affordable Luxury:
While Shashkay's glasses exude luxury and style, they remain accessible to a wide audience. With competitive pricing and frequent promotions, Shashkay ensures that high-quality, stylish eyewear is within reach for every man. glasses for men Gone are the days when premium fashion came with a hefty price tag – Shashkay proves that luxury can be affordable. glasses online Pakistan

Post a Comment