A Blog by Jonathan Low

 

Mar 26, 2018

How Does An Idea Become a Startup?

The days of raising millions and then figuring out if you have a viable business strategy have been supplanted by a lean startup approach. It emphasizes flexibility, prototyping, iteration and fast failure - or success - in order to identify a workable approach before seeking and committing significant capital. JL


Jennifer McFadden and Brad Hargreaves report in Yale Insights:

“We’re in an environment, now, where there’s no better time to try something new."  Lean Startup Methodology is a way to explore opportunities with less risk. Your prototype may not serve the same purpose or target the same audience, but it’s a useful product in its own right. “You don’t have to go all in. You can try something on the side. You can get a small project up and out. Sixty percent is the new eighty percent.”
How do you go from, “We knew there was a big opportunity in education, but we didn’t necessarily know what that was,” to a tech skills school with 20 campuses on four continents in seven years?
The answer is iteration, according to Brad Hargreaves YC ’08—the founder of the school in question, General Assembly, as well as three other companies, including the co-housing company Common. He talked lean startups with Jennifer McFadden ’08, Yale SOM’s associate director of entrepreneurship and co-founder of Skillcrush, in a February 7, 2018, webinar.
Hargreaves discovered entrepreneurship as a student at Yale. Trying to furnish their common space on the cheap, he and a roommate bought two card catalogs from a library the university was renovating. They hoped selling one on eBay would pay for the other. It ended up making a profit and led to a business helping Yale and other institutions liquidate similar items.
In 2011, he and three co-founders launched General Assembly. With little more than a hunch that they would do something in education, they created a set of single-session online classes that offered students a “cocktail-party-level” understanding of tech concepts. “It wasn’t a bad product at all,” Hargreaves said. “It let us build an audience. It let us develop our pool of instructors. It let us to get our operations going.”
A few months later they started offering 8- to 12-week classes in web development, data science, and UX design. They taught enough to add a skill on a resume but not enough to get a job. “Six months after that we launched our three-month full-time program in web development that actually got people jobs.” Today, its many full-time programs are the core of the business.
The evolution is a perfect example of lean startup methodology. “Your prototype may not serve the same purpose or target the same audience, but it’s a useful product in its own right,” Hargreaves said.
McFadden contrasted today’s approach with the late 1990s, when a company like Webvan would raise hundreds of millions of dollars in venture funding before talking with any customers. “We’re in an environment, now, where there’s no better time to try something new,” she said.  Lean Startup Methodology, she added, is a way to explore opportunities with less risk. “You don’t have to go all in. You can try something on the side. You can get a small project up and out.”
Quickly putting out an early iteration or minimum viable product (MVP in lean startup parlance) is a hallmark of the approach. How do you balance the efficiency of putting a prototype in front of consumers against ensuring a positive long-term reputation of the company? “Balancing brand and lean, sometimes you have to make hard tradeoffs,” Hargreaves said. “Even if you don’t invest in a brand, you still have a reputation. Customers are still going to talk about you, so thinking about it and building brand in from day one is critical.”
One way to build a buffer between early experiments and a full brand launch is using a pop-up company. When Hargreaves was exploring a real estate venture, he used a “working title” of Porchlight. It was little more than a website and a name to put on early tests aimed at gauging interest. When he and his team were clearer about the final product, they launched Common, a company that offers co-living apartments in four cities.
McFadden, who teaches the course Startup Founders Practicum at Yale SOM, noted that the Lean Startup Methodology is applicable to a range of organizations—for profit, nonprofit, or social enterprise, tech or consumer product. Regardless of the eventual sector, she said, “I encourage students to build a model, even if it’s rudimentary, early on.” She added, “If you put numbers down on paper, it forces you to think through issues you wouldn’t otherwise.”
While risk may be lower in starting a venture today than in the past, most entrepreneurs will eventually need to take a deep breath and decide to move ahead despite uncertainty. Google or Facebook may have the huge data flows to make choices with high confidence, but few others get that luxury. “Sixty percent is the new eighty percent,” McFadden quipped.
Hargreaves responded, “If you’re at 60% in the early days, you’re doing great.”
To reach any level of certainty requires figuring out some source of quick and inexpensive data to base decisions on. McFadden described Rent the Runway, an online dress rental company, which created a popup store to test whether women would be willing to rent dresses at all. When the company got a positive response, it followed up with an email-only offering to see whether customers would rent dresses without trying them on. Again, there was a positive response, providing proof points for moving ahead with the expensive steps of building a robust back end for the company.
“Email is still a great way to reach people,” Hargreaves said. “You can have an email list with 1,000 high-engaged subscribers and you’re 10 times more fundable, 10 times more interesting to a software engineer who’s thinking of joining your team.”
When developing teams, Hargreaves looks for complementarity. “The way I like to think about it is, ‘Where am I weak as an entrepreneur, given the idea I’m going after.” Whether it’s sectoral expertise, technical skillset, personality, or leadership gaps, awareness of individual and collective gaps is critical to building a startup team. As he launched Common, Hargreaves said, “I’d done product. I’d done technology. I’d done operations. I’d never done real estate.” His first two hires were a real estate finance expert and someone with real estate project development experience. While those were clear gaps, personality or leadership qualities can be harder to spot. “It’s so situational,” he said. “It’s a lot easier if you know yourself.”
Even with a great team, great idea, and great execution, “it’s going to get hard. It’s going to take longer than you think,” Hargreaves said. “There will be a slog even in a successful scenario.”
McFadden agreed, noting that to be sustainable, any venture has to fit into a entrepreneur’s life and rouse his or her passions. “Starting a venture is incredibly hard. Your probability of success is pretty small.”
Indeed, Hargreaves pointed out, while his biography lists four ventures—three of which he counts as successes—many ideas that didn’t get far enough to be counted. “A lot of things I tried didn’t work at all,” he said. “If you have 20 ideas and 3 work, that’s pretty good.”
His experience with both failed ideas and successful ventures has given him an appreciation of keeping an even keel, he said. “It’s never as good as it seems, nor as bad.” Today, he explained, he is better able to ride the ups and downs with some equanimity.
One tool for managing uncertainty is understanding the full spectrums of options across every axis of the business. Funding offers an example. The general rule of bootstrapping as long as possible before seeking investors isn’t inviolable. “Bootstrapping versus venture capital is a false dichotomy,” Hargreaves said. He encouraged entrepreneurs to be imaginative about funding, considering a full spectrum of options, including seeking early angel support, a small business loan, private-sector sponsors, pubic-sector grants, or a first customer who is willing to pay up front for a discount or for warrants in the company. Creativity and flexibility can expand opportunities.
Both General Assembly and Common are closely linked to the communities that that have grown up around them. “Community is the thing on top that takes it from a transactional experience to something magical, but you have to have a great product,” Hargreaves said. “The product has to come first. People don’t buy into a community in the abstract.”

53 comments:

realestate20 said...

thanks for share it was a great post

bestwnh79 said...

I really like your post, I always like to read a quality content having accurate information regarding the subject. Thanks for sharing. It is such a very amazing post...
hotel at manali

matka bank said...

I really like your post, Thanks for sharing. It is such a very amazing post...
Online matka play | Matka play | Play matka

hireseo123 said...

This is extremely helpful info!! Very good work. Everything is very interesting to learn and easy to understand. Thank you for giving information.
Visit website: seo services company|social media marketing company in india|social media marketing expert|top digital marketing companies in india

Van Rental San Francisco said...

europcar reviews, seattle car rental under 21 seattle car rental under 21 dallas love field rental car

devinhook said...

Use YouTube thumbnails, to sum up your videos with the help of PhotoADKing's YouTube thumbnail templates.

marketshare said...

I am new here. I like your post very much. It is very usefull post for me.
websit: Liquid Biopsy Market

buyonline123 said...

I am really enjoying reading your well written articles. I think you spend numerous effort and time updating your blog.
online electronics shopping sites in india

Andrew Smith said...

I Found Your Blog Very Much Informative. Thanks For Sharing Keep Sharing More. Hawkeye Kate Bishop Puffer Coat

deepaks42 said...

Hello there, I discovered your site by way of Google at the same time as looking for a
comparable matter, your site got here up, it seems to be good.
buy grocery online

jamesc32 said...

As we all know how much Bill of Sale being used. This document is usually used for sale and purchase between two parties like Buyer & seller.
Bill of sale

tomb said...

I definitely relishing every little bit of it. It is a great website and nice share. I optate to thank you. yellowstone black vest Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Excellent post it is very impressive and inspiring content thanks for share us keep it up

Andrew Smith said...

Have a look at amazingly crafted leather Jackets at a discounted price. Power book 2 jackets

Sam said...

Its awesome. Do you Want to take Realme Franchise, Realme Dealership, Realme Distributorship
Visit my Website Realme Franchise

Sam said...

Thank You for Providing Such insightful information. If someone is looking for the dushman ko jalane wali shayari.

ideasontrend said...


Its a really interesting and informative article for me. I appreciate your work and skills. Grace Sachs Green Coat

Unknown said...

For Android users, this is fantastic news. They can now effortlessly use it and install all of the programs that they require for any purpose. So, thank you for sharing us with us.
Gap Brown Hoodie

deanffranklin@gmail.com said...

I read this blog and I really imagine that it is captivating. Thnaks for offering such post to us! Eminent artical. Visit my site we have various thing naruto jacket

Real Jackets said...

Thanks for your marvelous posting! I certainly enjoyed reading lakers jacket starter
it, you might be a great author. I will ensure that I bookmark your blog
and will come back from now on. I want to encourage you continue
your great writing, have a nice holiday weekend!

deanffranklin@gmail.com said...

Today, I was basically investigating along and gambled upon your blog. Essentially expected to say incomprehensible blog and this article helped me a ton, taking into account which I have found definitively I was looking white fringe jacket

Unknown said...

Your article covers every one of the significant parts of the theme This is new information for me, I am amped up for it. much appreciate. blade runner 2049 jacket

Customer Service said...

Thank You for Providing Such insightful information. If someone is looking for the Quickbooks customer service in US.

Albert Watson said...

What is the composition of denim? and how much work is put into producing it? Denim was first created by hand shortly after its invention, but as time passed and technology advanced, machinery was developed to speed up the process. Star Lord Jacket The particular blue hue of denim is derived from a specific indigo dye that is generated synthetically in order to minimise expenses and speed up the entire process. Denim is made using one of two methods: the shuttle loom and the projectile loom.

Court Marriage Lawyers said...

We are the leading court marriage lawyers and marriage registration office in Karachi Pakistan catering to all the areas completely in Karachi our clients are from top industries businessman working brides and grooms we make court marriage registration very easy e and complete your document work

paulwin said...

This lovely crude oil is taken from hemp produced in Wholesale Full Spectrum CBD Oil Oregon and remedied at LaurelCrest Labs in Oregon after being winterized, de-carbed, and filtered. Available COAs include single origin, farm tracability, and full panel. the EU.

peter said...

The information shared by you is just mind blowing you're doing a great job for the blogging community like bape pink hoodie

peter said...

AMAZING..!!! I REALLY LIKE THIS WEBSITE SO MUCH IT’S ABSOLUTELY EXCELLENT TO ME IN RECENT TIMES I AM SIMPLY WAITING FOR YOUR NEXT BLOG Bape Hoodie

michael said...

I read this article. I think You put a lot of effort to create this article, keep it up.
Gaming Jacket

Harry Jacki said...

Spend no more time browsing and have a look at the numerous options for superhero jackets, celebrity jackets, and much more. Visit and place an order right now to stand out from the crowd in terms of fashion. Men Fur Jacket

Oneplus Franchise said...

its awesome, Do you Want to take Oneplus Franchise, Oneplus Dealership, Oneplus Distributorship

Visit my Website Oneplus Franchise

priya singh said...

thank you for this useful informations amd i found something is interesting here..
Plumbing contractor in Nagpur

michael said...

I am here to give a thumb-up on your work. really great and amazing content also helps to know about what the trend is going on. please Keep shearing these informative blogs and content.
david byrne big suit

pravesh singh said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Beautystyleinfo12 said...

Many years of experience in water purifier servicing and repairing industry. Website : Aqua Guard Water purifier service in Nagpur

reenas43 said...

IVC-Services is a private Consulting Agency. Visit here - korea visa application singapore

FAMILY LAWYERS KARACHI said...

Hello dear, I really like your blog your blog is very informative and knowledgeable thanks for sharing this type of content.

raju said...

I am very glad to here it is very good post Website :- seo services in delhi

Emily said...

Thank you for this useful informations. I like it. Kate Upton Astros Sweater

Linda Glori said...

"How Does An Idea Become a Startup?" is a concise and comprehensive guide for aspiring entrepreneurs, detailing the startup journey from ideation to execution. It emphasizes the importance of market research and validation, and provides practical tips. The article could benefit from real-world examples and case studies to enhance its narrative. It also emphasizes the importance of networking, mentorship, and funding options for a successful startup. Overall, it serves as a valuable starting point for those looking to turn their innovative idea into a successful venture.
New York Divorce Laws Assets

shailenewoodley said...

Stay cozy like the Lionesses while showing your support with this England Lionesses Puffer Jacket

SaraLawrence said...

Women Brown Leather Jackets are a classic piece of clothing. They are stylish and adaptable, lending a hint of edgy elegance to any ensemble. These jackets radiate confidence and style whether they're worn with jeans or a dress.




Chiku Cab said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

nice blog! Fantastic written! Thank You! Antique Books

Anonymous said...

Amazing! This blog is very important and i really like this blog! aviator jackets

Dawson said...

"How Does An Idea Become a Startup?" is a detailed guide for aspiring entrepreneurs, detailing the startup journey from conception to fruition. It offers practical tips and case studies, highlighting the challenges faced during the startup phase. The article also provides insights into overcoming these challenges and offers a roadmap for turning ideas into successful ventures.
trucking accidents

Sunglasses in Pakistan said...

We deal in Branded Sunglasses, Sunglasses in Pakistan, Sunglasses in Karachi, Best Sunglasses, Ladies Sunglasses

Post a Comment