A Blog by Jonathan Low

 

Sep 16, 2018

Pole Position: The Reason 5G Is Running Into Local Resistance

Telecoms want the right to put the hundreds of thousands of cells required wherever they want. Local governments want to be paid - and residents don't want unsightly poles, even as they demand better service.

Compromise seems possible, if not always likely. JL

Drew FitzGerald reports in the Wall Street Journal:
Cellphone companies plan to boost their capacity with several hundred thousand more cells to improve existing service and prepare for 5G service. Some of the local resistance is rooted in how small cells work. Small cells reach only a few hundred feet, so carriers need many more sites, usually on public land, for the system to work. “These poles are increasingly becoming valuable real estate that taxpayers paid to install."
Residents of Denver’s Riviera apartments were surprised earlier this year when a roughly 30-foot-tall green pole appeared a few feet in front of their building entrance. The pole, installed by Verizon Communications Inc. and laden with cellular antennas, was designed to improve cellphone service in the area, but the residents complained about the placement.
Months later, it was gone. But that was just a small taste of what’s to come across the country: Millions of Americans will soon encounter similar poles or notice antennas sprouting on existing structures, like utility poles, street lamps and traffic lights, all over their neighborhoods. All four national cellphone companies are pushing to build out their networks with a profusion of small, local cells to keep their data-hungry customers satisfied and lay the groundwork for fifth-generation, or 5G, service.
Those plans face pushback in many places, and not just from residents. Officials in some cities say they don’t have enough staff to process applications for dozens or even hundreds of new installations. In some smaller towns, officials say they lack the expertise to review the new technology, though they’re working fast to get up to speed.
In Wilton Manors, Fla., Mayor Gary Resnick says the Miami suburb needs more time to draft an ordinance to govern the installation of the new technology. And there are seasonal issues. “We generally restrict construction in the rights of way during hurricane season for obvious reasons,” he says.
Just around the corner
More than 100,000 small cells are already wired up across the U.S., according to industry research firm S&P Global . Cellphone companies plan to boost their capacity with several hundred thousand more cells to improve existing service and prepare for 5G service, which they see as a potential competitor for cable and fiber optics, among other things.
Some of the local resistance is rooted in how small cells work. Companies can usually find space on private property for large cell towers with a range of several miles. Small cells reach only a few hundred feet, so carriers need many more sites, usually on public land, for the system to work.
Cellphone companies don’t have much choice if they want to keep up with their customers’ appetite for data, says Jonathan Adelstein, chief executive of the Wireless Infrastructure Association, whose members include wireless carriers. “People wonder why they might be having a dropped call or slow video,” Mr. Adelstein says. “Then they have a vocal minority that are ruining it for everybody” by opposing the expansion of cellular networks.
Denver resident Brad Cameron says a new two-story pole that sprang up near his condo last winter “clearly has improved my cell service.” But he wants to keep new poles to a minimum by making cellphone companies share space on the same structures. “The concern I’ve got is that instead of trees, we’re looking at a forest of small cell towers,” he says.
Denver City Council member Wayne New says the government is encouraging carriers to cooperate with the local electric utility to use more existing street poles.
Policy battles
State and federal policy makers are mostly backing the wireless carriers. Federal Communications Commission rules passed in March exempt small-cell deployments from certain historic-preservation and environmental reviews. Another FCC rule slated for a vote this month seeks to lower local fees and would set 60-day or 90-day limits for local governments act on permit applications. A bill in Congress would deem small-cell applications granted if local governments fail to act on a request within 31 days. Dozens of state laws also restrict local governments’ control over small-cell projects.
“It’s all gamesmanship right now,” says Angela Stacy, vice president at consultant SmartWorks Partners LLC, who advises local governments on telecommunications policy. “The carriers have basically launched a three-pronged attack” with the support of regulators and federal and state legislators.
Officials in San Jose, Calif., have tried to parry that offensive by fast-tracking installations for carriers that have agreed to help fund a local internet-access initiative. The Silicon Valley city has licensed space on light poles for a few hundred dollars per installation, using the money to connect low-income residents to high-speed broadband at home. AT&T and Verizon have signed on to the plan and are gearing up to install equipment.
“We tried to prove to the telecom industry that cities are not the problem,” San Jose Mayor Sam Liccardo says. “We appreciate the industry’s position that too much red tape can get in the way.”
At the same time, though, Mr. Liccardo says the city and its allies are “battling the industry mightily” on the federal and state level, lobbying to block policies they consider a handout to cellphone companies because they would limit the fees the carriers can be charged to install and operate small cells.
“These poles are increasingly becoming valuable real estate,” he says. “If cities can’t manage their own infrastructure—that their taxpayers paid to install—it puts them at a considerable disadvantage.”
AT&T strategic-planning executive Jason Porter says cities’ needs vary but the company’s experience with San Jose is a “win-win.”
“Every concern that a city manager has is a viable concern,” Mr. Porter says. “San Jose’s a good example of a location that we’ve been able to work with.”
Making adjustments
Other local officials say the installations could widen the digital divide between well-connected residents and those with limited service. In Maryland’s Montgomery County, which covers rural communities and several suburbs of Washington, D.C., county planners are working on a fee structure for small cells. They want rental rates to vary depending on population density to encourage more rural deployment.
But in general, such fees take away from construction that ultimately benefits the public, says Rudy Reyes, a vice president of public policy for Verizon. “Capital budgets are limited, and we would rather use that money to invest in infrastructure and investment for our customers,” he says.
Construction isn’t slowing down in Denver, home of the since-removed pole in front of the Riviera apartments. The city now has nearly 100 small cells, with more than 250 additional installations planned. But the local government has set new guidelines to control where companies place their small cells, which prompted Verizon to take down a handful that it had already installed.
“They were willing to adjust to be good neighbors,” says Jon Reynolds, a program manager for Denver’s public-works department.
Verizon’s Mr. Reyes says Denver has been an overall success so far. “We try to work with these residents to address legitimate concerns,” he says.

69 comments:

Unknown said...

Thank you very much for writing such an interesting article on this topic. https://metaapk.com/minecraft-apk/ https://apkaero.com/hay-day-mod-apk/

Unknown said...

Thank you for this awesome article. It's a detailed information.
minecraft free full apk

Unknown said...

Thank you for this awesome article. It's a detailed information.
gta san andreas free download
Happy New Year wishes images

Ethan Mackloy said...

Hello, Thanks For sharing this nice information with us.
nvidia inspector
veterans day quotes

Aasif said...

Thank you for this excellent article. It's a detailed information. Looking forward for more.
idm full crack

Aasif said...

It is best article I have ever read. Thanks for this detailed article.
download msi gaming app full version
download pubg hack apk

Anonymous said...

Thanks for sharing, Nice post.
SBI care no

Go Getter said...

If you want to know more about nvidia,here is the blog that you will get detailed information on nvidian inspector
make sure you can check it out and keep on visiting and please share our blog.

Mietwagen 4 said...

standard sized cars, exotic car rental charleston sc exotic car rental charleston sc lax rent car

Bella spa said...

Hi! this is often nice article you shared with great information. We have young models who offer b2b massaging. Call us at 9900607853 to book an appointment.
Female to male spa near me

Sutra Massage said...

Looking for Full Female to male massage centre near me Service, Body Spa in Bangalore for female to male at our renowned sparsh body spa. Book now Nearby me.

spasweety said...

You can get a private room with the hottest ladies at one and only Body to body massage spa near me, i.e. Sweety Spa. Ladies play a huge role while going to a spa parlour and I bet you won’t find better ladies than sweety spa at any other spa for that matter.
Visit https://www.spasweety.com/

Rati Spa said...

We can help you find the best Body massage spa near me service for out-call services to keep your spa experience going at home.Nuru massage

spaleel12 said...

Nalini is a professional masseuse who specializes in Massage spa near me She has experience with deep tissue, sports and Body to body spa techniques. Nalini offers one-hour sessions that can be done at her spa or on location for your convenience.

nuru massage near me said...

We assure you world class nuru massage service in Bangalore.Bella spa having special nuru therapist where you can get 100% satisfied service.

Visit nuru massage near me

escorts hyderabad said...

we will do our best supports

lishasingh said...

Lishasingh is a massage therapist from Bangalore. He has worked over the last few years to provide top customer service massage parlour near me and support, for both male and female customers.He is always striving to become a better version of his self by ensuring high quality control throughout the day.Obedient6 minutes ago

lipikabri said...

In South Hyderabad You can enjoy the benefits of day spas, which mean all day for your own relaxation. You can take advantage of these spa services in hyderabad's luxury hotels, health clubs department stores, or spa centers. The models are charming to take care of and pamper your body. There are many luxurious benefits , like a massages and body wraps if you decide to not wear clothes. Massages are performed using aromatherapy and vitamin-rich oils. There are treatment for your body, beauty tips, and skin treatments. In addition you will body to body massage centres in hyderabad also get the luxury of a hot tub bath that takes away all fatigue and stress.

body to body spa near me said...

Female to male spa near you 24 hours provides professional spa treatments that will melt away your stress. Our professional therapists will pamper you to make sure that you feel relaxed, rejuvenated and looking your best.
female to male spa near me 24 hours

massage near me said...

weell exposed on it the best services

lishasingh said...

With us, you will not only receive a complete body massage, but also other options like Foot Massage as well as Body Scrubs and spa near to me Face Pack. Our prices are reasonable so that anyone can enjoy our services with no trouble.

Body to body massage in Chennai said...

Wonderful content thanks for this blog i like it

Anonymous said...

This month, we offer 25% off Regular customers
body to body massage in Bangalore can receive an additional 5% discount. Book a massage now by calling us. Get the best spa services in Bangalore

Neha Mari said...

Here at Bangalore girls, we're dedicated to providing you with a good time and ensuring that you leave happy. Our girls are all professional and dedicated to your satisfaction.

reshma said...

Our Bangalore Dating Girls are the right option for anyone who just wants some funny moments with a beautiful and charming model girl.

Anjali Meheta said...

Female Companions In Mumbai is something that has been in demand since the beginning of time. There are many reasons why men seek out female companionship, and in Mumbai, there are plenty of options to choose from. Whether you are looking for a date for a night out on the town, or someone to keep you company during a business trip, there are plenty of women who are happy to oblige.

massage near me said...

This month, we offer 25% off Regular customers can receive an additional 5% discount. Book a massage now by calling us. Get the best spa services in Bangalore
Book a Body Massage today by calling us. Receive 25% off any body massage

Goa Escorts said...

The woman in this picture is a hot-looking Goa Companion. She's also wearing a black fishnet dress with leather boots and a leather jacket. But is she the perfect, stylish, and aggressive sexy girl that you're looking for? That's up to you to decide.

Ishabasu said...

We have an extensive portfolio of Mumbai Models Girls available to book online. All of our models are beautiful, professional, and experienced. We have models available for all types of events, including fashion shows, product launches, photo shoots, and more. Contact us today to book the perfect model for your event.

punebeauties said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Bangalore Escorts said...

We have a wide range of beautiful and highly trained girls in Bangalore.

Mumbai call girls said...

We invite you to browse our hot and attractive Mumbai Call photo gallery and select your partner within a couple of minutes.

Ranchi call girls said...

Ranchi Companion < are some of the most beautiful and intriguing women you will ever meet. They are well-educated and well-spoken, and they know how to have a good time. They are the perfect companions for any occasion, whether you are looking for a night on the town or a quiet evening in. Ranchi is a city that has a lot to offer, and its Companion are no exception.

pooja bhati said...

I like these topics very much. I would like to see such topics daily, this post is very good indeed. There are people like you in the world who put forth their views. Thank you so much for posting such a great post.
Funny Story
Best Actor Of Gurugram
Best Food In Sector 24
Best Place In Haryana
Book Your Ticket Here
Awesome Servce Night Service
Funny Night In Sector 30
Lowest Price Service

CPS Test said...

Thanks for sharing such information – please look
CPS Test is a fun and engaging way to improve your hand-eye coordination and dexterity. By practicing regularly and trying to beat your own high scores, you can increase your clicking speed and accuracy, which can be useful in a variety of settings, from gaming to work and beyond.

Bathroom Gallery said...

Do you want to benefit from Efficiency Building India If this describes you, then come join Joy of Growing. We work under the promoter's objectives and regular advice. Business consulting collaborates with and for human resources to analyze and assess business processes as the organization attempts to maximize profit. For the project, we only engage one lead consultant per organization.

body massage in pune said...

We use disposable, hair-thin, sterile needles so you know you're safe.

divorce lawyers northern va said...

Very good news is shared in this article. It is very intresting article. I suggest you to keep publishing article like these.

priya roy said...

female to male massage in hsr layout encourage endorphin release through close contact and gliding motions, which promote muscular relaxation, ease tension, and treat pain.

Will Steven said...

Rappahannock Traffic Lawyer

Sussex is currently gripped with a spate of major car accidents, So you should need a Traffic Lawyer.

shanjanaarora said...

This type of technique might be uncomfortableb to b massage centre near me for some individuals, especially when the therapist is massaging the knots.

Richard said...

Good site for legal services, thank you so much for the sharing amazing experience. Abogado Conducción Imprudente Botetourt VA

female to male spa near me said...

Mind-Body Connection: Discussing the interconnectedness of mental and physical well-being and how neuromuscular massage contributes to holistic health.

lishasingh said...

During the application of massage a number full service massage in bangalore of physiological changes can occur such as an increase in temperature, cellular exchange, release of endorphins and decreased release of cortisol. T

rennasweety said...

This type of massage includes sensual massage in hyderabad compression of muscles, mobilization of joints, and acupressure.

Robert said...

motorcycle accident virginia
The article "Pole Position: The Reason 5G Is Running Into Local Resistance" discusses the challenges faced by 5G technology at the local level, focusing on the central theme of 5G resistance. The content flow is organized in a logical sequence, with data and evidence supporting the claims and arguments. The article includes local examples and a detailed regulatory framework, addressing common concerns raised by local communities such as health, privacy, and aesthetics. The article also discusses the policy impact of local resistance to 5G technology, its economic implications, and its global perspective. It compares the local resistance to 5G with similar issues in other regions or countries. The future outlook offers insights into the potential future of 5G deployment and whether resistance will continue to be a significant challenge. The article concludes with a call to action, prompting readers to consider the importance of balancing technological advancements with local concerns. It also includes a call to action, emphasizing the importance of public education and awareness campaigns in addressing misconceptions about 5G. The article also explores the scientific consensus on health and safety aspects of 5G technology, community engagement, public dialogue, environmental considerations, innovation and benefits, infrastructure challenges, social responsibility, network expansion, reader engagement, and future plans for further exploration of specific aspects of 5G technology and its impact on communities. In conclusion, this article provides an insightful look into the challenges faced by 5G technology at the local level, but it can be strengthened by incorporating data, diverse perspectives, and a balanced approach.

lingam massage in pune said...

Side plank — Sit on the floor with your right hand below your right shoulder and feet stacked.

Luxembourg Escorts said...

I’m really impressed with the detail you’ve provided on this blog.

Will Steve said...

Find the best Bankruptsy Lawyers Near Me, Our skilled lawyer will provide a legal advice.

glen said...

Amazing, Your blogs are really good and informative. I got a lots of useful information in your blogs. It is very great and useful to all. But that was just a small taste of what’s to come across the country: Millions of Americans will soon encounter similar poles or notice antennas sprouting on existing structures, like utility poles, street lamps and traffic lights, motorcycle accident i 95 virginia, Keeps sharing more useful blogs...

Robert said...

The Reason 5G Is Running Into Local Resistance
It's no surprise that the rollout of 5G technology has faced its fair share of controversy and opposition. While there are undeniable benefits to faster and more reliable internet connections, the implementation of 5G has been met with local resistance in many areas.
One of the key reasons behind this resistance is the concern over potential health risks. With 5G using higher frequency bands than previous generations, some people worry about the increased exposure to electromagnetic radiation. The lack of long-term studies on the health effects of this technology has fueled these concerns, leading to protests and demands for more research.
Another aspect of local resistance stems from the visual impact of 5G infrastructure. The placement of small cell towers and antennas necessary for 5G connectivity has been met with opposition from residents who feel that the aesthetic appeal of their neighborhoods will be compromised. This clash between the need for improved connectivity and preserving the visual harmony of communities has become a point of contention.
Overall, the resistance to 5G on a local level is multifaceted, combining concerns about health risks and visual intrusion. It highlights the need for open dialogue between telecommunication companies, local authorities, and communities to address these concerns and find solutions that balance progress and preservation.
Accidente de Camión


james vegita said...

This insightful blog sheds light on the evolving dynamics between telecoms, local governments, and residents. Balancing the need for expanded cell coverage with aesthetic and logistical concerns is a complex challenge. New Jersey Domestic Violence Act It's encouraging to see efforts in cities like San Jose to find win-win solutions that benefit both residents and telecom companies. Collaborative initiatives, like funding local internet-access projects, showcase the potential for positive outcomes in this rapidly advancing landscape. Great job capturing the nuances of this issue!Driving Without A License In New Jersey

KirstenSmallT said...

Searching for a Divorce Lawyers Arlington VA, Our skilled team is here to help you. Such a nice blog.

queenelizabeth said...

alexandria traffic lawyer
The article "Pole Position: The Reason 5G Is Running Into Local Resistance" provides a comprehensive analysis of the challenges and resistance faced by local communities in implementing 5G technology. It highlights the potential health and environmental impacts of 5G, as well as the role of local governments and regulatory bodies in addressing these issues. The article presents a well-researched argument, supported by data and expert opinions, that helps readers understand the complexities surrounding the deployment of 5G networks. It is a must-read for anyone interested in understanding the social, economic, and technological factors influencing the adoption of 5G technology.

Sarahdavid said...

dui lawyer prince william va
"Pole Position" is a documentary that explores local resistance to 5G technology, focusing on factors contributing to this resistance. It covers community engagement efforts, balances reporting, and examines the impact on aesthetics, health and safety, regulatory challenges, technological education, and environmental impact. The documentary emphasizes the need for increased awareness and understanding to alleviate fears and promote acceptance. It also discusses the environmental impact of 5G implementation, addressing concerns about energy consumption and the ecological footprint. The documentary concludes by considering the future implications of 5G technology and the importance of addressing local resistance.

ethanmax said...

The great content in this site good article also thanks for the information affordable lawyers near me

mathewjoy said...


The article "Pole Position: The Reason 5G Is Running Into Local Resistance" sheds light on the challenges faced by 5G implementation due to local resistance, primarily concerning the placement of infrastructure such as poles.

Examining the complexities of navigating local regulations and public concerns, the piece provides valuable insights into the hurdles faced by 5G deployment. The clash between the demand for enhanced connectivity and the need to address community apprehensions adds a layer of nuance to the 5G rollout.

By delving into the specifics of how the placement of poles becomes a focal point of contention, the article offers a comprehensive understanding of the local dynamics influencing the adoption of 5G technology. It's a compelling read for anyone interested in the intersection of technology and community engagement. abogado de dui en virginia

albertjamesen said...

Amazing, Your blogs are really good and informative. I got a lots of useful information in your blogs. The clash between the demand for enhanced connectivity and the need to address community apprehensions adds a layer of nuance to the 5G rollout contract dispute meaning. It is very great and useful to all. Keeps sharing more useful blogs....

ambrosed081 said...

Denver City Council member Wayne New suggests partnering with local electric utilities to use existing street poles to minimize the visual impact of small cell towers. This approach can streamline the installation process and reduce the need for additional poles, addressing residents' concerns about unsightly structures. However, collaboration between local governments and telecommunications companies is crucial to ensure compliance with regulations and safety standards. The benefits of this collaboration include efficiency, cost-effectiveness, environmental impact, aesthetic preservation, and regulatory compliance. wills and estates lawyer

Post a Comment