Ebooks Should Be Treated Like Physical Books For Library Lending, Says Europe's Top Court

The flip side of digital domination means you are not necessarily entitled to infinite profits. JL

Jennifer Baker reports in ars technica:

Public libraries should be allowed to lend e-books so long as the author is fairly compensated.
Electronic books should be treated just like physical books for the purposes of lending, an advisor to Europe's top court has said.
Maciej Szpunar, advocate general to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), said in an opinion published (PDF) that public libraries should be allowed to lend e-books so long as the author is fairly compensated.
A 2006 EU directive says that the exclusive right to authorise or prohibit rentals and loans belongs to the author of the work. However, countries may opt out of this rule for the purposes of “public lending,” provided that authors obtain fair remuneration.

Further Reading

Should it be legal to resell e-books, software, and other digital goods?

With e-book reselling heading to the EU Court of Justice, we examine the complexities of the law.

In the Netherlands, e-books do not fall specifically under that exception. But the association of Dutch public libraries—Vereniging Openbare Bibliotheken (VOB)—has argued that the rules should be the same for digital lending as for traditional books. It went on to bring a case against Stichting Leenrecht, an authors' rights collecting foundation.
Under VOB’s “one copy, one user” system an e-book at a library’s disposal may be downloaded by a user for the lending period, on the understanding that it is not accessible to other library users during that entire period.
At the end of that period, the book in question will automatically become unusable for the borrower in question and may then be borrowed by another user.
Szpunar believes VOB's method is fair under the law. He points out that bringing digital lending under the scope of the directive could lead to better security for authors, provided those e-books have been made available to the public by the rightsholder or with the their consent, and that the books are obtained from lawful sources.
The advocate general added that e-book lending hadn't been specifically included in the original directive because, at the time, the concept was “only in its infancy.”
A related case on the right to resell electronic books involving second-hand e-book service Tom Kabinet and the Dutch Publishers Association (NUV) will soon be considered by the Dutch High Court.