A Blog by Jonathan Low


Oct 18, 2018

The Big Blockchain Lie

Nouriel Roubini has very strong feelings about blockchain, as he does about many financial and economic topics.

Cryptocurrencies and their precipitous decline aside, his primary point is that the notion of decentralization is highly misleading since most blockchain based systems are, in fact, tightly controlled by a single individual or entity, just not by established governments or financial institutions - and those new ledgers have been hacked with alarming ease.

So, whatever it may eventually become, blockchain is not yet the panacea its hype promises. JL

Nouriel Roubini comments in Project Syndicate:

Blockchain is a glorified spreadsheet. But it has become the byword for a libertarian ideology that treats governments, central banks, traditional financial institutions, and real-world currencies as evil concentrations of power. Where distributed-ledger - enterprise DLT - are used, they are private, centralized, and recorded on controlled ledgers. They require permission for access and are based on trusted authorities that have established credibility. No serious institution would allow transactions to be verified by a cartel operating from the shadows of the world’s authoritarian kleptocracies.
Now that cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin have plummeted from last year's absurdly high valuations, the techno-utopian mystique of so-called distributed-ledger technologies should be next. The promise to cure the world's ills through "decentralization" was just a ruse to separate retail investors from their hard-earned real money.
With the value of Bitcoin having fallen by around 70% since its peak late last year, the mother of all bubbles has now gone bust. More generally, cryptocurrencies have entered a not-so-cryptic apocalypse. The value of leading coins such as Ether, EOS, Litecoin, and XRP have all fallen by over 80%, thousands of other digital currencies have plummeted by 90-99%, and the rest have been exposed as outright frauds. No one should be surprised by this: four out of five initial coin offerings (ICOs) were scams to begin with.
Faced with the public spectacle of a market bloodbath, boosters have fled to the last refuge of the crypto scoundrel: a defense of “blockchain,” the distributed-ledger software underpinning all cryptocurrencies. Blockchain has been heralded as a potential panacea for everything from poverty and famine to cancer. In fact, it is the most overhyped – and least useful – technology in human history.
In practice, blockchain is nothing more than a glorified spreadsheet. But it has also become the byword for a libertarian ideology that treats all governments, central banks, traditional financial institutions, and real-world currencies as evil concentrations of power that must be destroyed. Blockchain fundamentalists’ ideal world is one in which all economic activity and human interactions are subject to anarchist or libertarian decentralization. They would like the entirety of social and political life to end up on public ledgers that are supposedly “permissionless” (accessible to everyone) and “trustless” (not reliant on a credible intermediary such as a bank).
Yet far from ushering in a utopia, blockchain has given rise to a familiar form of economic hell. A few self-serving white men (there are hardly any women or minorities in the blockchain universe) pretending to be messiahs for the world’s impoverished, marginalized, and unbanked masses claim to have created billions of dollars of wealth out of nothing. But one need only consider the massive centralization of power among cryptocurrency “miners,” exchanges, developers, and wealth holders to see that blockchain is not about decentralization and democracy; it is about greed.
For example, a small group of companies – mostly located in such bastions of democracy as Russia, Georgia, and China – control between two-thirds and three-quarters of all crypto-mining activity, and all routinely jack up transaction costs to increase their fat profit margins. Apparently, blockchain fanatics would have us put our faith in an anonymous cartel subject to no rule of law, rather than trust central banks and regulated financial intermediaries.
A similar pattern has emerged in cryptocurrency trading. Fully 99% of all transactions occur on centralized exchanges that are hacked on a regular basis. And, unlike with real money, once your crypto wealth is hacked, it is gone forever.
Moreover, the centralization of crypto development – for example, fundamentalists have named Ethereum creator Vitalik Buterin a “benevolent dictator for life” – already has given lie to the claim that “code is law,” as if the software underpinning blockchain applications is immutable. The truth is that the developers have absolute power to act as judge and jury. When something goes wrong in one of their buggy “smart” pseudo-contracts and massive hacking occurs, they simply change the code and “fork” a failing coin into another one by arbitrary fiat, revealing the entire “trustless” enterprise to have been untrustworthy from the start.1
Lastly, wealth in the crypto universe is even more concentrated than it is in North Korea. Whereas a Gini coefficient of 1.0 means that a single person controls 100% of a country’s income/wealth, North Korea scores 0.86, the rather unequal United States scores 0.41, and Bitcoin scores an astonishing 0.88.2
As should be clear, the claim of “decentralization” is a myth propagated by the pseudo-billionaires who control this pseudo-industry. Now that the retail investors who were suckered into the crypto market have all lost their shirts, the snake-oil salesmen who remain are sitting on piles of fake wealth that will immediately disappear if they try to liquidate their “assets.”
As for blockchain itself, there is no institution under the sun – bank, corporation, non-governmental organization, or government agency – that would put its balance sheet or register of transactions, trades, and interactions with clients and suppliers on public decentralized peer-to-peer permissionless ledgers. There is no good reason why such proprietary and highly valuable information should be recorded publicly.1
Moreover, in cases where distributed-ledger technologies – so-called enterprise DLT – are actually being used, they have nothing to do with blockchain. They are private, centralized, and recorded on just a few controlled ledgers. They require permission for access, which is granted to qualified individuals. And, perhaps most important, they are based on trusted authorities that have established their credibility over time. All of which is to say, these are “blockchains” in name only.1
It is telling that all “decentralized” blockchains end up being centralized, permissioned databases when they are actually put into use. As such, blockchain has not even improved upon the standard electronic spreadsheet, which was invented in 1979.1
No serious institution would ever allow its transactions to be verified by an anonymous cartel operating from the shadows of the world’s authoritarian kleptocracies. So it is no surprise that whenever “blockchain” has been piloted in a traditional setting, it has either been thrown in the trash bin or turned into a private permissioned database that is nothing more than an Excel spreadsheet or a database with a misleading name.


casinositeone.JDS said...

I used to be check ing continuously this weblog and I 바카라사이트 am impressed! Appreciate it for your efforts.

casinosite777infoJDS said...

Really satisfied with all the information I have found in this article. 카지노사이트

casinositeguidecomJDS said...

Everything is very open with a really clear explanation of the challenges. It was definitely informative. 카지노사이트

Michael said...

เว็บบาคาร่าอันดับ 1 อย่าง Sagameherelao แจก สูตรบาคาร่าฟรี ผู้เล่นทุกคนสามารถนำสูตรบาคาร่าของเราไปปรับใช้ได้เลยตามความเหมาะสม สูตรบาคาร่ามีทั้งข้อดีและข้อเสีย สิ่งแรกที่คุณควรทำก่อนใช้สูตรบาคาร่าก็คือ ควรศึกษาวิธีการอ่านเค้าไพ่บาคาร่าให้ถี่ถ้วน เพื่อจะเป็นผลดีกับคุณ นอกจากนี้ เว็บไซต์ของเราเปิดให้บริการบาคาร่าออนไลน์ฟรีตลอด 24 ชั่วโมง สามารถเล่นผ่านโทรศัพท์มือถือ smartphone ได้ทุกระบบ ทั้งระบบ iOS และ Android และรองรับหน้าจอทั้งแนวตั้ง และแนวนอน เพื่อความสะดวกสบายให้กับผู้เล่น

ดูหนังออนไลน์ฟรี said...

Pleaseดูหนังออนไลน์ share this story as it is easy to access and easy to read. I want you to try to sit and think and review.

Post a Comment