A Blog by Jonathan Low

 

Nov 24, 2018

Are Pop Lyrics Getting More Repetitive

Language compression analysis, which eliminates repetitive lyrics, suggests the answer is yes.

And it's not all disco's fault. JL

Colin Morris reports in The Pudding:

The songs that reached the top 10 were, on average, more repetitive than the rest in every year from 1960 to 2015! 2014 is the most repetitive year on record. By 1980, disco has reached the peak of its popularity. The year's most repetitive song is Funkytown (85% compressible), which spends 4 weeks at #1. An average song from this year compresses 22% more efficiently than one from 1960.
In 1977, the great computer scientist Donald Knuth published a paper called The Complexity of Songs, which is basically one long joke about the repetitive lyrics of newfangled music (example quote: "the advent of modern drugs has led to demands for still less memory, and the ultimate improvement of Theorem 1 has consequently just been announced").
I'm going to try to test this hypothesis with data. I'll be analyzing the repetitiveness of a dataset of 15,000 songs that charted on the Billboard Hot 100 between 1958 and 2017.

Measuring repetitiveness?

I know a repetitive song when I hear one, but translating that intuition into a number isn't easy. One thing we might try is looking at the number of unique words in a song, as a fraction of the total number of words. But this metric would call the following lyric excerpts equally repetitive:
baby I don't need dollar bills to have fun tonight
I love cheap thrills
baby I don't need dollar bills to have fun tonight
I love cheap thrills
I don't need no money
as long as I can feel the beat
I don't need no money
as long as I keep dancing
~ Sia, Cheap Thrills
tonight I need dollar bills
I don't keep fun
cheap thrills long to feel money
the bills don't need the dancing baby
fun dollar dancing thrills the baby I need
don't have fun
no no don't have dancing fun tonight
beat the can as I don't feel thrills
love the dancing money
~ Colin Morris, Original composition
These are both 52 words long and use the same 23 word vocabulary, but the first one is clearly more repetitive, because it arranges words in a predictable, repetitive order.

Repetitiveness ≈ compressibility?

You may not have heard of the Lempel-Ziv algorithm, but you probably use it every day. It's a lossless compression algorithm that powers gifs, pngs, and most archive formats (zip, gzip, rar...).
What does this have to do with pop music? The Lempel-Ziv algorithm works by exploiting repeated sequences. How efficiently LZ can compress a text is directly related to the number and length of the repeated sections in that text.
Here's how it works.

Measuring Repetitive Lyrics With Compression

You can explore some examples of the algorithm applied to full songs here. It turns out, for example, that the entire lyrics of Cheap Thrills reduce in size 76% when compressed.
Is 76% a lot? Here's the distribution of size reduction percentages across (almost) all 15,000 songs in my dataset:

The Repetition of Pop Music

Distribution of compressibility of 15,000 songs from 1958 to 2017, excluding 20 outliers.
You may have noticed the percentages on the x-axis are not evenly spaced. I'm using a logarithmic scale with the property that, for any given song, a song that compresses half as small is a fixed distance away. For example, the distance between 20% and 60% is the same as between 98% and 99%. I'll be using this kind of scale throughout.
I excluded the 20 most repetitive songs in the dataset from the above chart. When you see what it looks like with them, you'll understand why:
What are these uber-repetitive outliers? Around The World by Daft Punk gets reduced a whopping 98%. It goes from 2,610 characters to 61. Small enough to fit in a tweet - twice!  

The Most Repetitive Songs

Of 15,000 songs from the Billboard Hot 100
intuitively, Around The World definitely feels like a very repetitive song. Several of the familiar entries on this list are essentially novelty songs (Macarena, Barbara Streisand, The Thong Song, Cotton Eye Joe...) famed for their silly refrains. This inspires some confidence in the metric I'm using.
So, is music getting more repetitive? The current decade is pretty well-represented in the top 10, but it's also a bit overrepresented in my dataset (it's easier to find lyrics for recent songs). We'll need to look at a lot more data to be sure...

Repetition of Popular Music, by Year

In 1960, the average song is 45.7% compressible. The most repetitive song of the year is Dee Clark's At My Front Door (78% compressible). Sample:
Knock, knock, knock, knock
Knock, knock, knock, knock

Crazy little mama come knocking
Knocking at my front door
Crazy little mama come knocking
Knocking at my front door
By 1980, disco has reached the peak of its popularity. The year's most repetitive song is Funkytown (85% compressible), which spends 4 weeks at #1.
2014 is the most repetitive year on record. An average song from this year compresses 22% more efficiently than one from 1960.
* Each point actually represents a 3-year rolling average. 2015 is the last year having a full year of data on either side of it.
** 22% is the relative difference. i.e. if we took random songs from 2014 and 1960 having the same length, we'd expect the compressed 2014 song to be 22% smaller than the compressed 1960 songs.
The songs that reached the top 10 were, on average, more repetitive than the rest in every year from 1960 to 2015!

Who's responsible for this madness?

Let's look at the average repetitiveness of some prolific artists in the dataset (those that have at least 15 charting songs as solo artists).

Repetitiveness Per Artist

Genre does seem like a differentiating factor here. In the 00's, our artists actually separate pretty cleanly into two clusters, with country music and hip-hop (and whatever John Mayer does) on the left, and pop and rock on the right.
The variation between artists is considerable. The Backstreet Boys have an average compression ratio of 60%, to Brad Paisley's 38%. In other words, if we asked the Backstreet Boys and Brad Paisley to each write a 400 word song, and compressed them both, we'd expect Brad's compressed song to be 50% bigger than BSB's.
Let's zoom in on a specific artist, say Gwen Stefani On average, Gwen's music is extremely repetitive, but there's a wide spread between the incessantly repetitive "Hollaback Girl", and the laid-back ballad "Cool", which is far less repetitive than the median song in the dataset.
A few interesting examples:
  • People have described 1989 as the album where fully transitioned from country singer/songwriter to popstar. This data adds some flavour to that claim. 4 of her 5 most repetitive songs are from 1989.
  • has a long, consistent legacy of highly repetitive music. Interestingly, her two least repetitive songs are arguably the only two that don't belong to the pop genre: they're both from the musical Evita, and written by Tim Rice and Andrew Lloyd Weber.
  • Rappers like and tend to be consistently non-repetitive.
  • Is it any wonder won the title of most repetitive artist in the dataset? Over half a dozen of her songs sit on the far right of the distribution (including, appropriately, Pon de Replay).

1 comments:

Post a Comment