A Blog by Jonathan Low

 

Oct 18, 2016

The Rise of the Truly Awful Webcam Interview

Resistance is futile: because, as the following article explains, the alternative is...nothing. JL

Rebecca Greenfield reports in Bloomberg:

Hilton got its hiring cycle down to 4.5 days, almost 20 days shorter than the average interview process. Cigna has cut travel expenses for recruiters from $1 million a year, in some cases, to under $100,000.Candidates will generally say, 'I would have preferred an in-person interview to this,' but that's not the right comparison. The alternative is no interview at all.
The future of job interviews might horrify you. It horrified Jake Rosen.
A recent graduate of UCLA, Rosen was applying to be a page at NBC (yes, yes, just like Kenneth) when he learned he wouldn't be going to an office to talk to a human being about his skills. Instead, he interviewed by webcam, on a laptop.
So Skype, right? Nope, nothing as personal as that. He recorded his answers and sent them back to a hiring manager at NBC for review at the company's convenience.
It's the robo-interview, and it goes something like this. In the more humane experience, a hiring manager, who also isn't all that practiced in the art of digital video, delivers taped questions. Or, if it's truly Mr. Roboto, a question pops up on the screen. You have a limited amount of time to answer. You talk to your computer, record the responses, and send them back to the company. Sometimes there's a practice question to get prospective employees used to talking to a camera. Sometimes there isn't. Often, at the end, you have the chance to re-record your answers.
For shy people, it may be a dream come true. No firm handshake needed, and sure, you smell fine. And wouldn't we all love the redo option after making up an answer and mumbling it, too?
For everyone else, it's awkward at best. It's a pretty slick encounter, a little like FaceTime, except you're forced to stare at your big, nervous face as you wax on about why you want to work at the company. It feels more like performing for an invisible audience than having a conversation, because that's essentially what it is. Not used to being on camera, Rosen felt flustered from the first question, which colored the rest of his interview, he said.
"I'm not a YouTube star, obviously," he said. "It's such a weird experience talking to a camera. It honestly was pretty horrible." Jamie Black, who suffered through the video interview experience for a job at a school, said it felt "more like a game show than an interview."
For many of us, the experience will soon be unavoidable. The human-free video job interview is on the rise. HireVue, one of a handful of companies making video interview software, works with 600 large organizations, including Deloitte, JPMorgan Chase, Under Armour, and most of the major U.S. airlines. This year, the company will do 2.5 million interviews, up from 13,000 five years ago. Nearly 90 percent of those are "on demand" interviews, with nobody live at the other end. 
For a hiring manager, the draw of the video interview is mainly efficiency.
"Companies want to get to know way more people," said Mark Newman, the founder of HireVue. A recruiter can only get through so many 30-minute conversations in a day. And that doesn't take into account time lost to scheduling or on bad candidates.
With a video interview, human resources staff members only have to review the answers, and can do so on their own schedule, without having to travel for on-campus recruiting. Using HireVue, Hilton got its hiring cycle down to 4.5 days, almost 20 days shorter than the average interview process. All of this saves companies money. Cigna has cut travel expenses for recruiters from $1 million a year, in some cases, to under $100,000. For the job candidate, the benefit of robo-recruiting is convenience—and that's about it. Generally, a company will give an interviewee a day or two to complete the interview, which can happen anywhere. That might sound like another plus, but for Rosen it only added to his stress.
"You start to think about things you wouldn't normally think about in interviews. I started thinking about my surroundings," Rosen said. "I had to find a blank wall to sit in front of. ... Should I put a bookshelf behind me? A plant?"
Recruiters say they don't judge candidates on their performance, appearance, or locale. "Judging is an interesting word," said Heidi Soltis-Berner, the managing director for talent at Deloitte. "I would say the on-demand interview is truly for fact sharing." Other recruiters said they do evaluate people on their communication abilities and eye contact.
Even if hiring managers are instructed not to make decisions on how well a potential new employee can perform in front of a camera (which is a bit hard to believe), the whole setup can be trying.
"You just see yourself and a stopwatch ticking down," said Black, who said his answers often got cut off by the timer.
If and when he has to do it again, Black said, he would practice in front of a mirror with a stopwatch before the interview. Rosen said it might help to have someone sit behind the computer, as the interview happens, so it's like talking to a person instead of a screen. Just look at the camera so your focus isn't off.
The best advice might be to just relax.
"It’s OK to come across as uncomfortable in front of the camera, because everyone is," said Scott Mitchell, a recruiter for American Wedding Group, which uses video interviews to prescreen the 1,900 independent contractors it works with. "We all assume you're going to be uncomfortable. We're putting you in an uncomfortable position."
The robo-interview hasn’t replaced human interaction completely. Many companies use it as a replacement for first-round screening interviews, followed by more traditional one-on-ones.
But for interviewees who would rather go back to the old way ... that's not happening. Organizations can look at more people, and a more diverse set of people, with the video interviews, and save money on top of that.
"Candidates will generally say, 'I would have preferred an in-person interview to this,' but that's not the right comparison," HireVue's Newman said. "The alternative is no interview at all."

46 comments:

essay center said...

As innovation shows signs of improvement and better, an ever increasing number of businesses are swinging to webcam interviews for starting meetings. This takes into account something approximating an up close and personal interview, yet without doing significantly more than would be essential for a phone meet.

Deanna Williams said...

You converse with your PC, record the reactions, and send them back to the organization. At times there's a practice question to get planned representatives used to conversing with a camera. Harrison Ford Star Wars Jacket

Unknown said...

You chat with your PC, record the responses, and send them back to the association Once in a while there's a practice question to get sorted out delegates used to bantering with a camera Interesting article Thankful to you for sharing them. Tom Hardy Cotton Jacket

Unknown said...

Skype interview are not so scary. I got my freelance job at Bestessays.com review just through a Skype interview. It saves your time and money when you live in another city. Only after you get a job you can bother yourself with moving.

SheritaGreen456 said...

So Skype right nope nothing as individual as that he recorded his answers and sent them back to a contracting administrator at NBC for audit at the organization's comfort. Trend Hoop

Unknown said...

The offer of your association resembles those people who have contribution in therapeutic, notwithstanding they don't manage weight, if the workload is developed the division so they free for all and start stirring up in their work.
Star Wars Darth Maul Tunic Robe Black Costume For Men

Kristin Legros said...

Magnificent article thank you for sharing them, I trust you will keep on having comparable presents to share with everybody. Filmstarlook

Unknown said...

creature throughout the world, and the declarations of the gospel contain not only truths encouragements, and precepts but also most awful warnings. Observe what power the. Kingsman Pedro Pascal Black Jacket

Mickey Mcginnes said...

creature throughout the world, and the declarations of the gospel contain not only truths, encouragements, and precepts but also most awful warnings. Observe what power the. Nick Nojas Jumanji Welcome To The Jungle Jacket

Emma Jason said...

If you're tired wearing same kind of jackets then you need to visit MauveTree.com they have variety of trendy and stylish leather jackets and you can customize your jacket as well! MauveTree

Mike Rooney said...

The ending of Rise of the Planet of the Apes was amazing. to dominate the earth. watch it yourself! It s truly amazing. Justice League Jason Momoa Jacket

Jessica Wil said...

To help keep your child safe while playing video games, find out about the multiplayer options of the games they are playing. Set age appropriate limits to gaming interactions with others online. Some games have parental control options that you can use to determine the kind of interaction your child will have with strangers. http://macgic.net

deepak ogen said...

I will deeply read your article and I will suggest to my all friends to visit your blog and get collect to helpful information you will mention on this superb blog keep sharing like this type useful article, thank you so much for share with us, If any one searching Website Designing Company please contact with us.
Web Designing Company in Delhi

Unknown said...

Such a awesome thinking you will be mention on this blog, I will also read this article properly am only say to thanks for share this useful and valuable information with us, I am sure your website will grow in the future, if any one need a shipping company in India please contact with us.
Sea Freight Company in India

Kala Kutir said...

I feel happy to learning this topic, I will read your blog deeply and happy to say this great work, you will many useful information put it on this article, thank you so much for share this valuable information with us keep share like this type topic and hope I see your again time with new topic, if any one change the lifestyle you will thinking about grow your looking and more etc.. please visit our website lifestylemagazine it’s help you to grow up your lifestyle, thanks to read my comment
Lifestyle Magazine

Qub Jordan said...

this looks like an amazing opportunity i will surely discuss Terminator Leather Jacket this with my other friends thanks for sharing.

denial patel said...

I don’t even understand how I stopped up here, but I assumed this put up was once good. Iron Fist Colleen Wing Bomber Jacket I don’t recognize who you’re however definitely you are going to a famous blogger when you aren’t already here.

Amelia Symond said...

Arhaus was founded and established on the simple idea that furniture should be sustainable. It has been in partnership with so many talented artisans worldwide that share the same ideology about furniture and craft the most reliable and gorgeous furniture range that carries forward the legacy of style and luxury in generations.

arhaus coupon code

seo work said...

Lots of great information and inspiration, both of which I need, thanks to offer such helpful information here.

Real Jackets said...

Appreciative for sharing an especially confounding post. It was really helpful. Keep on sharing more substance
Akira Kaneda Jacket

deanffranklin@gmail.com said...

Thankful for giving this best stuff to us! Continue to share! I'm new in the blog making. A wide degree of online journals and posts are not gigantic for perusers. Here the writer is giving satisfactory contemplations and idea to every single look at through this article click here. red puffer jacket

iLFORNO said...

Thanks for sharing this amazing post! I found many interesting things in it. Best Italian restaurant in UAE

Mike Rooney said...

Pretty cool post. It’s really very nice and useful post. Keep it up!!Spiderman Last Stand Jacket

Anna247 said...

Thank you for providing this vital information on your website. I'd want to express my gratitude for the efforts you put in to create this fantastic article.Yellowstone John Dutton Green Quilted Vest

Annapotus said...

Much obliged to you for giving this imperative data on your site. I'd need to offer my thanks for the endeavors you put in to make this awesome article. star lord jacket

Unknown said...

I constantly read the smaller articles as well as clarify their motives, and that also happens with this article!James Dean Jacket Rebel Without A Cause

Unknown said...

Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog.Tom Cruise Leather Jacket

Anna247 said...

The Jean Luc Picard Jacket is constructed of real leather and wool mix. This one-of-a-kind mix is what gives this jacket a trendy and sophisticated appearance. Star Trek Season 2 Picard Patrick Coat This jacket is black, giving it a neutral appearance that allows it to be worn with any pair of jeans.

Dorm Party said...

Very good knowledge you have shared. Do you wnat to rank your site through SEO

Derek Advert said...

Here is the article about the List of Best 5 All Rounders of the Asia Cup 2022.
Top 5 all rounders of Asia Cup 2022

Shopify development dubai said...

No event occurs by chance. ThroughoutShopify development dubai the past ten years, we have developed a methodical and deliberate writing, designing, and development process. We work to create magical branding with your help as a key collaborator in the design process.

envirosteam said...

While the future of job interviews may be different than what we're used to, it's important to remember the benefits of virtual interviews such as reduced travel costs and faster hiring cycles. Similarly, trying a new Car Wash Ottawa may be different, but it could also lead to a better and more efficient experience.

hastenchemical said...

Although virtual interviews may not be ideal for some candidates, they offer a viable alternative to no interview at all. And for businesses that need to transport their hiring equipment or materials, reliable Reefer Truck Shipping – Texas can ensure that everything arrives safely and on time.

Charbonnel said...

While in-person interviews may be preferred by some candidates, virtual interviews can still provide an effective means of assessing job fit. On a side note, chocolate truffle in Dammam are a decadent treat that can be found in many confectionery shops in Dammam.

Vava Store said...

It is very interesting blog. People can get opportunity for the jobs by reading this blog. thanks for sharing this. However searching for best quality leather jacket like jungle cruise costume with high quality material made and with the latest style design.

chrispine said...

Join the ranks of anime's most notorious group while staying cozy in Naruto Akatsuki Puffer Jacket

hastencatering said...

The prevalence of truly awful webcam interviews is a growing concern in the digital age. It's crucial for both candidates and employers to invest in better equipment and preparation to ensure a smoother and more professional experience. And if you're hosting a virtual Cocktail party catering services in Pecos Texasmake sure to elevate the event with exquisite cocktails and catering from ABC Catering to leave a lasting impression on your guests! 🎥💼🍸

curbsidecar said...

The Rise of the Truly Awful Webcam Interview highlights the challenges of virtual job interviews. In a world where impressions matter, consider the importance of a pristine car with Ceramic Coating services in Ottawa. Just as a polished interview leaves a positive impression, a well-maintained vehicle showcases attention to detail and professionalism in every aspect of life.

Vava Store said...

Very nice blog. I really enjoyed reading your post. looking for best quality leather jacket like Spider man tuxedo with bst fashioable design with good quality and durability and made from good quality material. you can take it on events and trips.

electra dubai said...

The article sheds light on the challenges of webcam interviews. In a world of remote interactions, a reliable setup is crucial. Consider kdk exhaust fan in uae for quality ventilation solutions, ensuring a comfortable and distraction-free virtual meeting environment.

Alexander_01 said...

As remote work becomes more prevalent, so does the rise of truly awful webcam interviews. From technical glitches to awkward silences, these virtual meetings present unique challenges. Navigating them successfully requires preparation, professionalism, and adaptability to ensure a positive impression in the digital realm. "Your comment is like a burst of confetti, adding joy to our blog. Each word is a brushstroke on the canvas of conversation, creating a vibrant tapestry of ideas. We eagerly await your next insight, as your contributions light up our digital world. Thanks for being our comment superstar!" virginia reckless driving ticket

Future Style said...

Nida Faysal's Future Style is the embodiment of fashion forward-thinking, skillfully fusing modern aesthetics with classic refinement. It establishes the foundation for the development of style in the modern era with painstaking attention to detail and a flair for invention.

Relax said...

Indulge in ultimate relaxation at Relax Massage center, where skilled therapists soothe away tension and stress with expert techniques. Immerse yourself in a tranquil oasis and experience rejuvenation like never before.

CMOLDS Dubai said...

CMOLDS is a premier mobile app development Dubai, offering cutting-edge solutions tailored to your business needs. With expertise in mobile app development, we craft innovative and user-friendly apps that propel your brand forward in the dynamic digital landscape.

Aamish Khan said...

Ramma Foundation Repair specializes in Edmonton foundation repair services, offering reliable solutions for all your foundation needs. With expert knowledge and quality craftsmanship, we ensure your property's foundation remains strong and stable for years to come.

Post a Comment