A Blog by Jonathan Low

 

Feb 10, 2019

Why Even Amazon Now Says It's Time To Regulate Facial Recognition

Amazon has been under attack since its facial recognition technology demonstrated rather blatantly that it contains inherent biases against people of color. That the company continued to try to sell its technology to various federal, state and local law enforcement agencies despite the findings, added to concerns that it was more concerned about the sales than the efficacy of its product.

That it is now calling for regulation suggests it belatedly recognizes that what could be imposed on it will be far more restrictive than legislation it could take a hand in drafting. JL


Shirin Ghaffary reports in Vox:

The debate about Amazon’s use of the technology has intensified because of evidence of racial bias and errors with the tool. Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella said the company would welcome regulation to prevent the market from becoming a “race to the bottom” that could lead to “even more heavy-handed regulatory regimes.” Google promised not to sell facial recognition software until it works through “important technology and policy questions.” Despite Amazon’s calls for transparency, the company  has been accused of withholding information about its work with police. “Amazon’s framework rings woefully hollow.”
Amazon released a blog post  proposing ethical guidelines around the use of facial recognition technology and called for national legislation on the topic.
The company’s own facial recognition software, called Rekognition, has been mired in controversy since its public debut two years ago. Rekognition can track people in photos or video and run those images against databases of millions of images in real time. The tool is currently used by at least one US law enforcement agency to help identify criminals. Dozens of civil rights groups and several lawmakers have expressed concern that the tool could be used for more widespread government surveillance — but Congress has yet to introduce legislation on the topic.
The debate about Amazon’s use of the technology in particular has intensified because of evidence of racial bias and errors with the tool, such as when the ACLU ran a test on the software and found that it misidentified 28 members of Congress as matching with criminal mugshots — disproportionately mismatching members of color. (In it's blog post, Amazon wrote that the “service was not used properly” in such cases.) The company has also come under fire for pitching its software to ICE, according to documents obtained by the Project on Government Oversight. Critics such as the ACLU worry that ICE could use the software to unjustly target immigrants with greater efficiency.
There have been calls both from civil rights organizations and Amazon’s own rank-and-file employees to stop selling the product to government agencies.
Today’s note, penned by Amazon VP of Global Public Policy Michael Punke, is in direct response to some of those concerns.
“New technology should not be banned or condemned because of its potential misuse,” Punke wrote in a blog post on Amazon’s website on February 7. “Instead, there should be open, honest, and earnest dialogue among all parties involved to ensure that the technology is applied appropriately and is continuously enhanced.”
This isn’t the first time a major tech company has called for self-regulating facial recognition software. Just a few weeks ago, Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella said the company would welcome regulation in the field to prevent the market from becoming a “race to the bottom” that could lead to “even more heavy-handed regulatory regimes.” In December, Google promised not to sell facial recognition software until it works through “important technology and policy questions.”
Amazon’s proposals include some suggestions that are already a given (“Facial recognition should always be in accordance with the law”), but also some stronger ones. For instance, when law enforcement agencies find a suspected criminal match, they should have a real human being review the case before making an arrest. Another proposal called for law enforcement agencies to provide regular transparency reports to the public on how they’re using the software, and to notify the public with written signage when they’re being surveilled with facial recognition technology.
Critics of the software say that Amazon’s proposals don’t go far enough — and that the company’s actions contradict its statements.
For example, despite Amazon’s calls for transparency, the company itself has been accused by lawmakers of withholding relevant information about its work with police.
“Amazon’s framework rings woefully hollow,” wrote ACLU Senior Legislative Counsel Neema Singh Guliani in email, adding that it “underscores the company’s refusal to properly address the dangers of its technology in government hands and reinforces the urgent need for Amazon to get out of the surveillance business altogether.”

39 comments:

robin.smithsters said...

If you are looking for test banks online, the best place for Testbank Downloads would be TestBanksOnline. Do not wait to buy Cultural Anthropology Appreciating Cultural Diversity 15th Edition Test Bank online anymore. Get Test Banks Download and improve your grades.

Unknown said...

Thanks for sharing. I found a lot of interesting information here. A really good post, very thankful and hopeful that you will write many more posts like this one.
health tips in urdu

Adam Lee said...

Introduction of new consoles with wireless connectivity and rising number of gamers will drive the demand for the gaming console market worldwide.

kevin malone said...

Solutions of Quickbooks Database Server Error- Firstly, Uninstall Quickbooks Desktop, to do this you have to press Windows+R keys together then open the control panel, then choose the program or features option then uninstall the program, then choose Quickbooks desktop from the list of the installed program then choose uninstall or change the option and follow the on-screen instructions. Secondly, install the latest Windows firewall option- first press the Windows+R key and open the run dialogue box then type Control firewall.cpl in the text box and press Enter then check that if the updates are available then update it once the updates are installed restart your Windows pc.

Sarthak jain said...

Enjoy celebrating occasions in Chennai with hassle-free online cake delivery through Gifola. Make your loved ones relish the rich taste of delicious cakes

order cake online chennai

Gifola Gifts said...

Sending gifts is easier now with GINBOX, no recipient address required, greater discount and faster checkout. Grab your globally unique & favourite GINBOX number and share it with friends and start receiving gifts.

Send Gift Using Ginbox

Marcel Mikaelson said...

The increasing utilization of smart beds in the healthcare industry due to the increasing automation and improving patient room technology represents one of the key factors creating a positive outlook for the Smart Bed Market.

Procurement Resource said...

DAP (Diammonium Phosphate), also known as diammonium hydrogen phosphate, is a water-soluble ammonium phosphate salt and a phosphatic fertiliser. It has excellent soluble properties with high nutrient content which makes it a popular choice in farming, agriculture, and other industries. It is also used as a fire retardant and as a yeast-nutrient in winemaking to sustain yeast fermentation.


DAP Production Cost

Monnika Jacob said...

My first experience with facial recognition was not satisfying, but I hope with the passage of time Amazon will overcome its shortcomings. Buy Essay Online

Software Crafts said...

Software craft is a leading affordable web development services that provide cutting-edge engineering solutions for global companies and helps companies accelerate the adoption of new technologies. Moreover, the software created by our team of professional experts can perfectly meet the needs of users and businesses and is easy to expand, integrate and support. Along with this, we provide a flexible cooperation model, provide transparent services, and are always prepared to take end-to-end responsibility for project results.

Oncasinosite Net said...

I envy your piece of work, appreciate it for all the good content. 카지노

Totopick Pro said...

There is perceptibly a lot to realize about this. I believe you made various nice points in features also. 토토사이트

Anonymous said...

QTa3y3

o8utiuu said...

t3t3ttg

werisegoc said...

We Rise GOC is a rising name in the Real Estate Market. Members of We Rise GOC’s aim to be a recognized leader for innovation and excellence in the Real Estate industry.

Rakhi Saxena said...

There are different kinds of versatile fixing institute in Delhi. They give you fundamental to cutting-edge degrees of preparation in the technological world. As we a whole realize we as a whole are becoming socially accommodating nowadays and cell phones, PCs, and different contraptions have turned into a need for each individual around us. So this course will genuinely assist you with filling in from here on out and leading your profession in fixing the world. These courses involve portable fixing, PC fixing, LCD fixing, OCA fixing, EMMC fixing, etc.
Call here for more data 9212411411.

Visit Here :- Mobile Repairing Course In Delhi

Gaming Pro Max said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Gaming Pro Max said...

Mr Beast YouTuber said: "In our diversion of Willy Wonka's chocolate manufacturing plant we have Gordon Ramsay, a chocolate cascade/waterway, and a specially constructed distribution center loaded with sweets difficulties to conclude who wins it."

Ramsay has turned into a web symbol for his blazing explosions and image commendable put-downs. Also, episodes from his TV shows 'Ramsay's Kitchen Nightmares USA' and 'Damnation's Kitchen' have turned into a firm #1 for decorations to respond to during their livestreams. He's no more peculiar to web distinction either, and runs an exceptionally famous TikTok account.

Obviously, the tweet got consideration with fans who were energized by the information. Nonetheless, MrBeast wasn't the main YouTuber who figured out how to get a snap with Ramsay.

Ryan Cooper said...

Quickbook file doctor will be useful for users in resolving some errors like network issues, 6000 series errors. QuickBooks file doctor is a free tool offered by Intuit QuickBooks. So, in this article,
we’ll go over how to use Quickbook File Doctor. Read More

Malta Assignment Help said...

Nice Blog
Need assistance with your academic assignments in Malta? Look no further than Malta Assignment Help. Our expert team of writers provides high-quality Assignment Help in Malta that is tailored to your needs. With our 24/7 customer support and affordable prices, you can trust us to deliver exceptional work every time.

Malaysia Translators said...

Nice post
When it comes to certified translation services Malaysia, malaysiatranslators.com is the name to trust. Our team of expert translators ensures that your documents are accurately translated to the highest standards. Whether you need legal, medical, or technical documents translated, we have you covered. Contact us today for reliable certified translation services in Kuala Lumpur and beyond.

Greece Assignment help said...

Great post
Need reliable and efficient dissertation writing services in Greece? Turn to Greece Assignment Help for exceptional master dissertation writing services greece tailored to your specific needs.

Wilson said...

Thanks for your amazing blog with us. I read a content, I really appreciated you for your great work to share an information.
attorney to contest protective order virginia

Anonymous said...

Thanks for your amazing blog with us. Car Detailing Vaughan

Anonymous said...

This is extremely exceptionally decent post you shared, I like the post, a debt of gratitude is in order for sharing. zabiha halal

Sophie Owens said...

Ireland Assignments is the perfect place to get professional dissertation writing help in Ireland. With our team of experienced and qualified writers, you can be sure that your dissertation will be crafted with precision and experience to give you the best results at affordable prices.

My Translation Services said...

Good blog

At our translation company in UK, we believe that communication is key to success. That's why we offer a comprehensive range of translation services, including document translation, website localization, and interpreting. Our team of experienced linguists can help you connect with customers and clients in any language, ensuring that your message is clear and effective. Visit our website to learn more about our translation services and how we can help you break down language barriers.

Preslin said...

Good informative content to read. Thanks for sharing this beautiful post. Keep sharing more interesting blogs. DUI Lawyer Frederick VA

Classy Artz said...

"Preserve the beauty of your cherished varmalas with Classyartz.com Varmala Preservation Services. We offer expert preservation techniques to keep your precious memories intact for a lifetime. Trust our skilled artisans to carefully clean, repair, and protect your varmalas, ensuring their longevity and sentimental value. With our meticulous attention to detail, your varmala will remain a symbol of love and union for generations to come."

ROLEX WILLIAM said...

Amazon, once an advocate, now acknowledges the necessity to regulate facial recognition technology due to its potential risks and misuse. This shift reflects growing concerns about privacy and ethics. Abogado de tráfico de Southampton

CV Writing Services said...

Want to secure your dream job in Ireland? Our top-rated CV writing services can help. We offer the best CV writing services in Ireland, ensuring your resume shines among the competition. Our expert writers optimize your CV with the right keywords and formatting, increasing your chances of success. Don't miss out on the job of your dreams – choose the best CV writing services in Ireland.

Advina Jhons said...


In New Jersey, divorce laws involve both fault and no-fault grounds. Couples can file for a no-fault divorce based on irreconcilable differences, provided they have been living separately for at least 18 consecutive months. Alternatively, fault grounds include adultery, desertion, cruelty, and more. New Jersey follows equitable distribution, where marital property is divided fairly but not necessarily equally. Spousal support may be awarded based on factors like financial need and contribution to the marriage. Residency requirements and legal processes must be adhered to for a valid divorce.
divorce in new jersey laws




Sarah Lillian said...

In New Jersey, separate from regulations include both shortcoming and no-issue grounds. Couples can petition for a no-issue separate from in view of beyond reconciliation contrasts, gave they have been living independently for something like 18 successive months. Then again, issue grounds incorporate infidelity, departure, mercilessness, from there, the sky is the limit. New Jersey follows evenhanded dissemination, where conjugal property is partitioned decently however not really similarly. fairfax divorce lawyer || winchester traffic lawyer || is new jersey a no fault state for divorce.

james anderson said...

Amazon's acknowledgment of the need for facial recognition regulation reflects growing concerns about bias and privacy. Transparency and accountability are crucial. Let's hope for meaningful legislation to protect civil rights.
Cheap Divorce Lawyers in New York

Amy Jhons said...

Lawyers in Orange County offer expert legal counsel across diverse fields including civil litigation, family law, and real estate. Renowned for their professionalism and dedication, Orange County attorneys navigate complex legal matters with precision, ensuring client advocacy and justice prevail in this vibrant Californian community.
lawyer orange county

Post a Comment