A Blog by Jonathan Low

 

May 6, 2016

Why the Tech Industry Cares If Artificial Intelligence Can Be Ethical

As devices and the software that drives them become increasingly integrated and interactive with humans, the transference of knowledge is not just limited to skills and tasks, but to values and norms.

The challenge in a multi-cultural world is determining whose values and whose norms.

This is important not just at a philosophical and existential level, but because decisions made now may affect the success of future relations between devices and humans, with all of the socio-economic implications for acceptance, growth - and profits - that suggests. JL

Peter Singer comments in Project Syndicate:

With driverless cars already on California roads, it is not too soon to ask whether we can program a machine to act ethically. But driverless cars are not superintelligent beings. Teaching ethics to a machine that is more intelligent than we are, in a wide range of fields, is a far more daunting task. The unpredictability of the environment may reveal a software error that has disastrous consequences.
Last month, AlphaGo, a computer program specially designed to play the game Go, caused shockwaves among aficionados when it defeated Lee Sidol, one of the world’s top-ranked professional players, winning a five-game tournament by a score of 4-1.
Why, you may ask, is that news? Twenty years have passed since the IBM computer Deep Blue defeated world chess champion Garry Kasparov, and we all know computers have improved since then. But Deep Blue won through sheer computing power, using its ability to calculate the outcomes of more moves to a deeper level than even a world champion can. Go is played on a far larger board (19 by 19 squares, compared to 8x8 for chess) and has more possible moves than there are atoms in the universe, so raw computing power was unlikely to beat a human with a strong intuitive sense of the best moves. Instead, AlphaGo was designed to win by playing a huge number of games against other programs and adopting the strategies that proved successful. You could say that AlphaGo evolved to be the best Go player in the world, achieving in only two years what natural selection took millions of years to accomplish.
Eric Schmidt, executive chairman of Google’s parent company, the owner of AlphaGo, is enthusiastic about what artificial intelligence (AI) means for humanity. Speaking before the match between Lee and AlphaGo, he said that humanity would be the winner, whatever the outcome, because advances in AI will make every human being smarter, more capable, and “just better human beings.”
Will it? Around the same time as AlphaGo’s triumph, Microsoft’s “chatbot” – software named Taylor that was designed to respond to messages from people aged 18-24 – was having a chastening experience. “Tay” as she called herself, was supposed to be able to learn from the messages she received and gradually improve her ability to conduct engaging conversations. Unfortunately, within 24 hours, people were teaching Tay racist and sexist ideas. When she starting saying positive things about Hitler, Microsoft turned her off and deleted her most offensive messages.
I do not know whether the people who turned Tay into a racist were themselves racists, or just thought it would be fun to undermine Microsoft’s new toy. Either way, the juxtaposition of AlphaGo’s victory and Taylor’s defeat serves as a warning. It is one thing to unleash AI in the context of a game with specific rules and a clear goal; it is something very different to release AI into the real world, where the unpredictability of the environment may reveal a software error that has disastrous consequences.
Nick Bostrom, the director of the Future of Humanity Institute at Oxford University, argues in his book Superintelligence that it will not always be as easy to turn off an intelligent machine as it was to turn off Tay. He defines superintelligence as an intellect that is “smarter than the best human brains in practically every field, including scientific creativity, general wisdom, and social skills.” Such a system may be able to outsmart our attempts to turn it off.
Some doubt that superintelligence will ever be achieved. Bostrom, together with Vincent Müller, asked AI experts to indicate dates corresponding to when there is a one in two chance of machines achieving human-level intelligence and when there is a nine in ten chance. The median estimates for the one in two chance were in the 2040-2050 range, and 2075 for the nine in ten chance. Most experts expected that AI would achieve superintelligence within 30 years of achieving human- level intelligence.
We should not take these estimates too seriously. The overall response rate was only 31%, and researchers working in AI have an incentive to boost the importance of their field by trumpeting its potential to produce momentous results.
The prospect of AI achieving superintelligence may seem too distant to worry about, especially given more pressing problems. But there is a case to be made for starting to think about how we can design AI to take into account the interests of humans, and indeed of all sentient beings (including machines, if they are also conscious beings with interests of their own).
With driverless cars already on California roads, it is not too soon to ask whether we can program a machine to act ethically. As such cars improve, they will save lives, because they will make fewer mistakes than human drivers do. Sometimes, however, they will face a choice between lives. Should they be programmed to swerve to avoid hitting a child running across the road, even if that will put their passengers at risk? What about swerving to avoid a dog? What if the only risk is damage to the car itself, not to the passengers?
Perhaps there will be lessons to learn as such discussions about driverless cars get started. But driverless cars are not superintelligent beings. Teaching ethics to a machine that is more intelligent than we are, in a wide range of fields, is a far more daunting task.
Bostrom begins Superintelligence with a fable about sparrows who think it would be great to train an owl to help them build their nests and care for their young. So they set out to find an owl egg. One sparrow objects that they should first think about how to tame the owl; but the others are impatient to get the exciting new project underway. They will take on the challenge of training the owl (for example, not to eat sparrows) when they have successfully raised one.
If we want to make an owl that is wise, and not only intelligent, let’s not be like those impatient sparrows.

20 comments:

Groumpfy said...

AI doesn't exist and will not for the foreseeable future. The Taylor fiasco proved again that what popular media call AI are just huge data base full of everything you put in it (trash in -> trash out) there is no intelligence in repeating the stupidities you were told!

AlphaGo just used good inputs (thousands of human games) to build a reliable database that allows it to play well.

What you call AI is as "intelligent" as a parrot repeating songs they have heard.

Anonymous said...

To the comment above me, (that started with: "AI doesn't exist and will not for the foreseeable future") Then how do you define intelligence? aren't our intelligence also is based on learning from others but just using better techniques than the current AI ones? Btw, I'm not saying you're wrong about what you said, I just want to get a deeper understanding of what intelligence really is.

saman-satan said...

ساخت تیزر تبلیغاتی یکی از محبوب ترین شیوه های تبلیغاتی است.
https://mobito.ir/teaser/
به وسیله ساخت تیزر تبلیغاتی، همواره در اوج هستید.

Sam said...

Buy new branded watches from Exclusive Watches, Our new product Royal Oak Double Balance 41mm Green Titanium was introduced in 2020. It marks the first time the Royal Oak is fitted with the self-winding caliber AP 2950 movement previously exclusive to the CODE 11:59 collection.

Sam said...

Hire Line Heights for WordPress websites. Its a best WordPress Development company in Uk , with qualified developers. Hire them for most responsive and fastest website for your business.

zahra said...

buy your socks from linktr.ee

Irelandassignmenthelper said...

Great blog
Welcome to Ireland Assignment Helper, your one-stop solution for professional academic writing services in Ireland. Are you looking for someone to write your assignment in Ireland? Look no further! Our team of skilled writers is here to provide you with high-quality assignments tailored to your specific requirements. Trust us to deliver plagiarism-free, well-researched, and error-free assignments on time. Contact us today and let us help you achieve academic success!

Irelandassignmenthelper said...

nice post
Looking for reliable QQI assignment help online in Ireland? Look no further than Ireland Assignment Helper! We provide top-quality, personalized QQI assignment solutions that meet your unique requirements. Our team of skilled writers is committed to delivering original and well-researched assignments that meet the highest academic standards. We understand the importance of timely submission and ensure that your assignments are delivered on time, every time. Trust us for all your QQI assignment help needs in Ireland. Contact Ireland Assignment Helper today and take the first step towards academic success!

ireland assignment help said...

Our "do my online exam Ireland" service is tailored specifically to meet the needs of students in Ireland. We have a team of Irish professionals who can complete your exam for you and ensure that you receive a high score. Our services are fast, reliable and affordable and we guarantee that you will be satisfied with the results. We provide a comprehensive range of services to ensure that your online exam is completed efficiently and accurately. Our team of experts will ensure that your online exams are completed on time and with the highest level of accuracy. We also provide support and guidance throughout the entire process, so you can be assured that your online exam will be completed successfully.

Malta Assignment Help said...

Trustworthy essay writing services in Malta provided by skilled writers. Experience exceptional quality and personalized assistance for your essays.

Malaysia Translators said...

Nice post
In need of professional translation services in Malaysia? Look no further than Malaysia Translators. With a diverse range of offerings, including medical, legal, business, and technical translations, our certified translators ensure precise and reliable results. Experience the highest level of quality translation services in Malaysia at affordable prices. Visit our website now and get started on your translation project.

allproblemsolving said...

Discover the art of creating a hanging indent in Word with AllProblemSolving's expert guidance. Our user-friendly tutorial provides detailed instructions and tips to help you effortlessly incorporate this formatting style into your documents. Take your writing to the next level and showcase your professionalism with a perfectly formatted hanging indent.

Vegita said...

This blog post is incredibly uplifting and informative. I love how you've presented the information in such a clear and engaging way.Abogado de Conducción Imprudente Condado de Middlesex Your positivity is contagious, and it's truly inspiring to read your thoughts. Thank you for sharing this wonderful content!

Antony said...

I have read your article, it is very informative and helpful for me.I admire the valuable information you offer in your articles.
Federal Criminal Defense Lawyer

Tdavidluiz said...

I gathered more useful information from your blog.
Abogado Tráfico Fairfax VA

Advina Jhons said...

For those dealing with traffic violations in Hanover, VA, enlist the assistance of an experienced traffic lawyer. Our Hanover office specializes in traffic law, offering personalized representation to minimize fines and safeguard your driving record. With a comprehensive understanding of local regulations, we provide strategic defense tailored to your specific case. Trust our team to advocate for your best interests. Contact our Hanover, VA office today for expert assistance and guidance in addressing your traffic-related legal matters.

traffic lawyer hanover va



Sarah Lillian said...

This blog entry is unimaginably inspiring and educational. I love the delightful way you've introduced the data in such a reasonable and connecting way. divorce lawyer in fairfax || divorce laws new jersey|| divorces in virginia.

marshtravis said...


Virginia's uncontested divorce rules simplify the process and may save time and money by allowing couples to amicably agree on issues like child custody and asset allocation without the need for court intervention.
virginia uncontested divorce laws

Amy Jhons said...

Hanover County DUI attorneyIn the event that you're confronting a DUI allegation in Hanover Province, enrolling a talented DUI lawyer is fundamental. A proficient lawyer can challenge proof, arrange supplication arrangements, and attempt to limit the effect on your record and driving honors. They will give master direction through the legitimate cycle, expecting to accomplish the most ideal result for your case. In Hanover Region, experienced DUI lawyers are focused on protecting your freedoms and tying down a great goal to your DUI circumstance.

Post a Comment