It bears repeating: Americans dont just dislike AI, they hate it. Which is odd, because the US rise to wealth and power was fueled by new technologies - water power, the steam engine, power looms, railroads, electricity, the auto, telephones, even the internet - all of which were embraced fairly quickly.
But in the 26 or so years since the dotcom era, we've learned a few things about digital tech, which has raised the popular degree of skepticism. Wall Street and corporate execs may have been thrilled to hear AI would eliminate lots of jobs - but most people were not. And the degree of tech driven wealth concentration followed by tech bro arrogance and cluelessness - we're looking at you, Jeff Bezos, Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg, Marc Andreesen, et al - has only added to the public loss of trust and rise in hostility, which has been exacerbated by the mortgaging of the economy and political system to their insatiable demands for more money, electricity and water, all at the expense of that selfsame public. So to paraphrase a TV ad from the 80s, 'tech generated public enmity the old-fashioned way, they earned it.' JL
Paul Krugman reports in his substack:
In 2015, Pew found 71% of the public said tech companies “have a positive impact on the way things are going in this country.” In the past Americans greeted emerging technologies with optimism. So what accounts for the current hostility against AI? First, we fear AI will do terrible things because the companies selling it told us it would do terrible things. Anthropic's CEO declared AI could wipe out half of entry-level white-collar jobs and drive unemployment up to 20%. Second, people feel AI is being forced on them. Third, datacenters occupy huge tracts of land, guzzle electricity, water and create pollution. 57% of Americans - 66% of Democrats, 50o% of Republicans - oppose datacenters in their neighborhood. Finally, AI is linked in the public mind with the tech oligarchs who are pushing it. There is widespread awareness of the growing concentration of wealth and power at the top. Tech has lost the public's trust.