A Blog by Jonathan Low


Jan 2, 2020

Why Only You Can Prevent Digital Dystopia

We have met the enemy and yes, she is us.

Regulating social media and big tech is a meaningless exercise if human digital behavior does not improve. JL

Farhad Manjoo comments in the New York Times:
Social networks and governments are looking into ways to curb viral misinformation. This fight will define our age. The root of the problem is that humans are weak, gullible dolts; every day many of us, people who should know better, fall for online hoaxes. What distinguishes productive online communities from disturbing ones? Clear, well-enforced guidelines. Twitter and Facebook are toxic because there are few rules and few penalties for flouting them. Virality hijacks our better instincts, and because the internet’s business models benefit from instant popularity, there’s a great deal of money and power riding on our failings.

The new year is here, and online, the forecast calls for several seasons of hell. Tech giants and the media have scarcely figured out all that went wrong during the last presidential election — viral misinformation, state-sponsored propaganda, bots aplenty, all of us cleaved into our own tribal reality bubbles — yet here we go again, headlong into another experiment in digitally mediated democracy.
I’ll be honest with you: I’m terrified. I spend a lot of my time looking for edifying ways of interacting with technology. In the last year, I’ve told you to meditate, to keep a digital journal, to chat with people on the phone and to never tweet. Still, I enter the new decade with a feeling of overwhelming dread. There’s a good chance the internet will help break the world this year, and I’m not confident we have the tools to stop it.
Unless, that is, we are all really careful. As Smokey Bear might say of our smoldering online discourse: Only you can prevent dystopia!
And so: Here are a few tips for improving the digital world in 2020.
If I were king of the internet, I would impose an ironclad rule: No one is allowed to share any piece of content without waiting a day to think it over.

Continue reading the main story
Virality was once the delightful miracle of a networked age; you’d see a funny video going around, get caught up in the collective wonder and hilarity, and forward it on to your 100 closest pals. At its meme-ified best, participating in this sort of viral feast felt like a boon to collective social bonding. Remember, kids, that one glorious day we were all talking about the crazy dress? What times, what times!
But, The Dress notwithstanding, in the 2010s virality got too easy, and then it grew sour, venal and dishonest. Nobody’s counting, but by my unscientific estimate almost everything that became instantly popular online in the last decade turned out to be problematic in one way or another. That photo of the shark washed onto a freeway by a hurricane? Fake. The culture-war-defining outrage your aunt just posted to Facebook? Debunked, of course. The suddenly popular influencer? A “milkshake duck” running from his past.
Social networks and even governments are looking into ways to curb viral misinformation, but this fight will define our age. The root of the problem is that humans are weak, gullible dolts; every day many of us, even people who should know better — folks with fancy jobs and blue check marks next to our handles — keep falling
for online hoaxes. Virality hijacks our better instincts, and because so many of the internet’s business models benefit from instant popularity, there’s a great deal of money and power riding on our failings.
There is only one long-term fix: that a critical number of us alter how we approach viral content. Let’s all consciously embark on a mind-set shift. In 2020, question anything that everyone’s talking about, especially if it fits all your priors, or there’s some kind of ad money involved. (Hint: There’s always ad money involved.) If you can’t stop sharing, at least slow your roll. The stakes are enormous; there’s no room for error. Strive to be better, please.
In the 2010s, Twitter became the center of the political universe. In some ways this was for the better — Twitter is a haven for righteous activism against the global powers that be — but most times, it was for the worse. Twitter is a daily toxic nightmare of reflexive egotism and groupthink that will prompt you to question your priorities, not to mention your sanity.
Which is why, if you’re on Twitter and can’t muster the will to never tweet, you should at least consider it your duty in 2020 to resist the network’s worst impulses, for your sake and all of ours, too.
What’s Twitter’s most damaging sin? I say it’s the too-easy mocking joke — what’s known, in the jargon, as the “quote-tweet dunk.”
Here are two canonical examples:
This scurrilous maneuver works like so: You spot an easily ridiculed tweet by a member of some rival social or political tribe. Like a 1990s fourth grader with phasers set to “Moded!” you add a pithy rejoinder that’s sure to please your side. It’s best if you elide context, depth or any intention of dialogue; just straight-up make fun of the person. Then mash on the retweet button to broadcast your supposedly clever jape.
The mechanism is part of the problem — when you quote-tweet someone on Twitter, the service shows off your remark to your own followers while leaving the original poster’s followers in the dark. (Another Twitter feature, the Reply, lets followers of both users see a response.) If Twitter is a cocktail party, the quote-tweet dunk is the equivalent of overhearing a guy across the room say something ridiculous, then inviting the whole room to point and giggle at the idiot over there. The imbalance discourages any possibility of meaningful conversation and reduces all of political discourse to empty, shallow quippery.
The thing about the quote-tweet dunk is that it can feel incredibly intoxicating; in the heat of some white-hot political moment, it’s always tempting to shoot the fish in the barrel and watch the Likes roll in. I swore off dunks years ago, but I still find myself aping Michael Jordan now and again.

Continue reading the main story
Twitter could instantly improve itself by removing quote-tweet as a feature. Failing that, take the oath with me: If the joke’s too obvious to resist, let it go.
It can sometimes seem as if all the internet is deep fakes and culture wars, Trump tweets and influencer scams. It’s not, of course. The internet still abounds in lovely, wholesome niches — the fantasy sports circles, the YouTube and Instagram communities devoted to any kind of craft, the many subreddits where strangers come together to help one another out of real problems in life.
What distinguishes the productive online communities from the disturbing ones? Often it’s something simple: content moderation. The best places online are bounded by clear, well-enforced community guidelines for participation. Twitter and Facebook are toxic because there are few rules and few penalties for flouting them. A Reddit community like r/relationships, meanwhile, is a haven of incredible, empathetic discussion because its hosts spend a lot of effort policing the discussion toward productive dialogue.
This gets at the plain truth of the internet: A better digital world takes work. It’s work all of us should do.


Unknown said...

Bola Basket adalah website sumber berita - berita tercepat dan teraktual yang ada di Internet, dari berita yang sedang Viral di dunia dan juga di Indonesia

Unknown said...

Nonton Black Clover Sub Indo

Nonton update - update anime black clovers terbaru hanya ada di AnimeMalam.com. Nonton Black Clover Sub Indo update 1 minggu seklai dan update tepat pada waktunya dengan subtitle indonesia yang tepat serta kualitas video dengan kualitas terendah yaitu 480 sampai dengan kualitas paling tinggi yaitu HD. Semuanya hanya ada di Animemalam.com
Tempat Nonton Anime

lk21pagi said...

LK21Pagi adalah Situs Nonton Film Online Gratis yang ada di Indonesia, LK21Pagi menyediaka beragam genre - genre film dan juga film - film paling lama sampai dengan film - film terbaru di Tahun 2019 dan 2020 ini, semuanya menggunakan Subtitle Indonesia dan juga kualitas vidio yang tinggi sampai dengan kualitas HD

Nia Wijaya said...

Then mash on the retweet button to broadcast your supposedly clever jape.
The mechanism Situs BandarQ Online is part of the problem — when you quote-tweet someone on Twitter, the service shows off your remark to your own followers while leaving the original poster’s followers in the dark

Nia Wijaya said...

situs qq bandarq online resmi pkv games, kami merupakan salah satu situs penyedia game judi domino qq online yang bermain dengan menggunakan uang asli Situs Agen BandarQ

Nia Wijaya said...

LigapokerQQ adalah Situs PKV online terbaik dan agen judi bandarq deposit pulsa terbesar dan menyediakan games dominoqq online uang asli Indonesia

King4d said...

king4d is the largest and most trusted online lottery gambling site in the world by providing an official online lottery market from a trusted online lottery expenditure and will get a deposit bonus every time you make a deposit every day. With the lowest minimum deposit of 50K, you can immediately play all the games in King4d reliably.

King4d said...

indotogel is the safest and most trusted gambling gambling place in the world by providing SGP data, Sydney data and legal HK data directly from trusted online lottery releases.

Pubg mobile said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
CTH Bazaar said...

Very nice and informative content
Thank you and have a pleasant day,
Please visit our website
Buy fresh chicken online: https://cthbazaar.com/product-category/raw-chicken/

Anonymous said...

Best choice ini merupakan situs data hongkong yang sangat banyak memberikan traffic kepada orang.

bestbus said...

I enjoyed reading the post. Thanks for the awesome post.
Best Mobile App development company in Hyderabad

Educational Services said...

Thanks For Sharing such a wonderful article the way you presented is really amazing It was extraordinarily simple to discover my way around and amazingly clear, this is staggering!!!
Best Software Training Institutes

Rohan Singh said...

I would love to read your posts again and again. Also, I will wait for your next post. AppSquadz is helping businesses with their concerns get in touch with us for more help. Also visit: flutter development company

Unknown said...

arunnn providing facebook likes at very low price. Get your facebook page likes just 24 hours.

Top Web Design company in Hyderabad

Cyberworx said...

Actually, I was searching for some information tips. And I found your article. This is a great article. Thanks for sharing, please keep sharing! SEO Agencies in India | Best Website design Companies in Bangalore | Web Development Agency in Hyderabad

Gurjeet Singh said...

It’s your time to take your business to a next level by making it online with a feature laded, fully functional and responsive website. And adding a cherry on the top is our pragmatic and effective mobile app development solutions to take your website amongst millions of mobile users. Not only this, get high converting traffic by making a strong online presence with our digital marketing and search engine optimization services. If this isn’t it, then our unique branding solutions will definitely bound you to associate with us. I know you’ve made your decision, our information is given below. Feel free to reach out to us. Web Designing Company In Delhi

Gambar said...

Jangan lupa untuk mengunjungi situs tercepat dan terbaru.
data sgp
data sdy
data hk

onlyblog said...

Nice Blog. Thanks for sharing with us. Such amazing information.

The safest jobs in covid-19 across globe



Live Draw SGP said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

your post having Creative & valuable content keep posting
Corporate film makers in hyderabad

Unknown said...

is one of the popular부산피쉬아로마 movies downloading website.Here you can download all hollywood, Bollywood, south indian, Bhojpuri, hindi dubbed movies easily.This site is known now for its easy and user friendly dashboard for its new comers.

Unknown said...

This is a good time to make long term plans and it's timely.
Have fun. I have read this post, and if you will excuse me, I would like to advise you on 강화외국인출장안마
영월외국인출장안마interesting topics or tips.
You can write the following articles on this topic.
I want to read more topics on this topic!

maybe Mahi said...

"I like the helpful information you provide in your articles. I will bookmark your blog and check again here regularly.This blog article is really good, can give me innovation to create a website. Thank you very much
avg tuneup crack
k7 total security crack/a>
advanced systemcare pro crack/a>
bulk image downloader crack
bulk image downloader crack"

Anonymous said...

If you have a business website, you are probably interested in hiring a good web design company in Hyderabad to help you create a visually appealing website. These companies can maximize brand visibility on digital media, make websites faster, and create an effective interface.

Anonymous said...

If your television has become unusable due to faults with the screen, audio system, or other systems, you should take it to a Sony Tv repair Hyderabad service center for assistance. These certified experts will diagnose the problem quickly and provide a quick solution.

Anonymous said...

A variety of marble polishing services Hyderabad offers comprehensive restoration and repair services for marble floors. Service providers use industrial-grade tools and cleaning agents to restore marble floors to their original luster.

Anonymous said...

Our Washing Machine Service Center in Vijayawada is equipped to repair all brands of washing machines. We have the best technicians to fix your washing machine's problem as quickly as possible, no matter what type of washing machine it is. We charge moderate fees for our technicians and our service centre specialists are extremely skilled in dealing with washing machines. All you have to do is call us, and our technicians will be there to help you.

Anonymous said...



live draw hk

live draw sydney

forum syair hk

forum syair sydney

Unknown said...

I really happy found this website eventually. Really informative and inoperative, Thanks for the post and effort! Please keep sharing more such blog. 인천출장마사지

Anonymous said...

I was very happy to uncover this great site.
tafsir mimpi

satyaET said...

Thank you for sharing information organic honey

hokabet said...

Very inspiratif, like very much, the best articles ever.
โปโมชั่น hokabet

Live Draw Sdy said...

Thank you for the information that has been provided here, because it is very useful.

Live Draw Hk said...

thank you for all the information that has been conveyed here, hopefully it can be useful.

Post a Comment