A Blog by Jonathan Low

 

Feb 22, 2023

The Reason Upgraded Ukrainian Tanks Are Defeating Newer Russian Armor

Ukrainian crews are better trained and more highly motivated. 

But as importantly, Ukrainian mechanics and logistics personnel are skilled - and not inclined to sell spare parts and fuel for personal profit like Russian repair staff do. JL 

Stavros Atlamazoglou reports in Business Insider:

A Ukrainian T-64BV and a Russian T-72B3 tank fought a deadly duel in the east of the country. Despite being older, the Ukrainian armor took out its Russian adversary with a single long-distance shot. The victory of the Ukrainian crew is a testament not only to the quality of their training but to the skill of their engineers and mechanics, who upgraded many of the older, Soviet-designed models into the tanks Ukraine is now fielding. The modernization packages included digital radios, internal communications, navigation systems, thermal sights, and modified dynamic protection.

A rare video from the frontlines shows one of Ukraine's upgraded Soviet-era tanks outperforming one of its newer Russian adversaries.

In the footage, published online in December, a Ukrainian T-64BV and a Russian T-72B3 tank fought a deadly duel in the east of the country. Despite being older, the Ukrainian armor took out its Russian adversary with a single long-distance shot.

A Ukrainian drone recorded the fight. On the outskirts of a destroyed town, the Ukrainian tank is advances down a road, straight toward the Russian tank. Without stopping, the Ukrainian tank fires a round at its adversary. After a direct hit, the Russian T-72B3 explodes.

In technical terms, the tanks Russia has deployed are often newer and more advanced than the Ukrainian tanks they're facing, but the victory of the Ukrainian crew is a testament not only to the quality of their training but to the skill of their engineers and mechanics, who upgraded many of the older, Soviet-designed models into the tanks Ukraine is now fielding.

Update or buy new?

Kyiv Ukraine tank turret factory
A tank turret is repaired at the Kyiv Panzer factory in August 2015. 
NurPhoto/NurPhoto via Getty Images

As Kyiv sought to modernize its military following Russia's 2014 attack, it had to decide between purchasing a battalion of new armor — about 50 tanks — or modernizing as many as four battalions of older tanks, which could be done for the same price, according to a Royal United Services Institute report on the first several months of the war.

It chose the latter and updated part of its T-64 and T-72 fleets. The modernization packages included digital radios, internal communications, navigation systems, thermal sights, and modified dynamic protection, among other upgrades. Since then, the West has helped Ukraine modernize more of its aging Soviet-era tanks.

When the war began, however, the 2,800 "combat-ready tanks" in Russia's invasion force vastly outnumbered the Ukraine military's total of about 900 tanks, according to the report.

Many of the tanks in those two forces were the same models and had similar vulnerabilities — one of which was demonstrated vividly in the early months of the war.

Soviet- and Russian-made tanks are designed for a crew of three — driver, gunner, and commander. Instead of a loader they have an automated loading system, which stores ammunition in the turret.

With limited protection in the turret and rounds stored elsewhere in the tank, enemy fire can more easily detonate the tank's ammunition, causing a "jack-in-the-box" effect that sends the turret flying sky-high.

Western tanks are designed with a sealed ammunition storage space and have fourth crew member who loads rounds into the gun.

More victories, better weapons

Ukrainian troops inspect a destroyed Russian tank
Ukrainian troops inspect a destroyed Russian tank near Kupiansk in the Kharkiv region in December. 
SERGEY BOBOK/AFP via Getty Images

Ukraine's requests for newer, more advanced Western-made tanks to replace its older, Soviet-era tanks — some of them older than the troops using them — are longstanding, but before the war, there were financial and logistical limits on the kinds of weapons Ukraine could acquire.

When the war began, pressure from Russia led Kyiv and its supporters to focus on weapons that were familiar to Ukrainian troops and could be used right away, such as Soviet-origin Mi-17 helicopters and T-72 tanks, or that would be easier to integrate, such as M113 armored personnel carriers, older air-defense systems, and low-tech drones.

But in late summer and the fall, Ukraine took the initiative, forcing Russian troops into retreat. The battlefield has largely stabilized, and Ukraine can now afford to send some troops to train for more complicated operations using more complex weapons.

Ukrainian troops this month began training for combined-arms operations — which require coordination between aircraft, ground troops, artillery, and armored forces — and have begun or will soon begin training on other weapons, including the US-made Patriot air-defense system and Western armored vehicles.

US-made Abrams, German-designed Leopards, and British-built Challenger 2 tanks are some of the more than 300 heavy tanks that have been promised to Ukraine in recent weeks.

Despite growing arguments about the relevance of tanks on modern battlefields, both Russia and Ukraine have employed tanks effectively and routinely rely on tanks to break their adversary's defenses, even with the proliferation of anti-tank weapons.

Ukraine claims to have destroyed or captured more than 3,000 Russian tanks, though Oryx, an open-source investigation outlet, has only visually verified about 1,600 of those.

As of January 25, the US has committed more than $27.1 billion in security assistance to Ukraine since Russia attacked on February 24, 2022 — a total of less than 5% of the US defense budget that has helped destroy thousands of Russian tanks, armored vehicles, and artillery pieces.



6 comments:

Tonia Mcgregory said...

Jabodetabek private tutoring services with teachers going to the house. More than numerous active tutors decide to teach various skills and lessons for kids to adults ... click https://privatmurah.vercel.app/les-privat-pademangan-murah.html for more details

Benito Rav said...

Very best along with Lowest priced Jabodetabek Individual Instruction, our personnel along with tutors can come to your residence, fixed your own personal research program which enables it to choose any subject involving examine ... click https://privat-inggris.netlify.app/kursus-bahasa-inggris-bekasi.html for more details

Earnest Onstad said...

Perhaps you will discover a cheaper fee versus the table above, be certain again around the qualifications of the teacher / Kindergarten teacher recommended for you ... for detail https://fisika-exed.blogspot.com/2022/04/les-privat-fisika-di-jakarta-barat.html

shane said...

The Lowdown Blog offers readers a diverse range of engaging articles, covering various topics from technology and lifestyle to entertainment and current events. With a team of expert writers and contributors, this blog aims to provide insightful perspectives and valuable information on the latest trends and issues. Whether you're looking for product reviews, thought-provoking opinion pieces, or updates on pop culture, The Lowdown Blog is your go-to source for staying informed and entertained."
Abogados de Divorcio Tysons Virginia
Divorce Attorneys Fairfax VA
Divorce Lawyers Spotsylvania VA

thomas said...

Amazing, Your blogs are really good and informative. The modernization packages included digital radios, internal communications, navigation systems, thermal sights, and modified dynamic protection bankruptcy lawyer chapter 7 near me. I got a lots of useful information in your blogs. It is very great and useful to all. Keeps sharing more useful blogs..

sopfiaa said...

Thank you for breaking down the complexities of the types of divorce in New York State. Your blog post is a great starting point for individuals looking to understand the various options available. Your clarity and insights are much appreciated!
Tipos de Divorcio en Estado de Nueva York

Post a Comment