Phillips O'Brien reports in his substack:
Hackers from Ukraine and Belarus were able to get their hands on 23 terabytes of data from the official Russian state statistics agency, Rosstat. These documents look legitimate. They have been reported on widely from the Moscow Times to the Financial Times. Moreover, they cover all deaths, so can be used to cross-check with non battlefield deaths (and the figures match). What the documents showed was that Russian reporting of their war dead is months behind— a long lag between the death on the battlefield and it being recorded. The second was that even with this lag, Russian deaths as of August were recorded as landing somewhere between 400,000 and 450,000, meaning Russian deaths in the war are “on track” to reach 650,000.For years it has been convenient for pro-Russian organizations and advocates to say that the Ukrainian claims of Russian casualties (which certain western intelligence agencies considered credible) were wildly inflated. It was said that there was no way that the Russians could have lost so many dead, and moreover Mediazona, which was operating by using released Russian figures, had a number much, much lower.
Well, we finally have some figures that have been taken from hacked Russian documents, and they tell a very different story. A group of hackers from Ukraine and Belarus were able to get their hands on 23 terabytes of data from the official Russian state statistics agency, Rosstat.
And these documents look absolutely legitimate. They have been reported on widely from the Moscow Times to the Financial Times. Moreover, they cover all deaths, so can be used to cross-check with non battlefield deaths (and the figures match).
Now, what the documents showed was twofold. The first is that Russian reporting of their war dead is months behind—there seems to be a long lag between the death occurring on the battlefield and it being recorded. The second was that even with this lag, Russian deaths as of August were recorded as landing somewhere between 400,000 and 450,000.
Some statisticians have taken these official figures and done some basic calculations. If that was the state (with a lag) in August, the real death toll at that time was probably between 500,000 and 550,000. The larger figure was one reached by the Financial Times. Furthermore, the FT then calculated out where things should stand by the end of the year, and they came to the conclusion that Russian deaths in the war were “on track” to reach 650,000. Here was a chart from their piece.
This proves two important points. One, Russian losses are not sustainable at the current rate. If the war goes on as is, and the Russians cannot change this, it will lead to a steady degradation in their fighting power. Indeed, we arguably have seen signs of that degradation all summer, as the Russians have started to lose more ground than they can take.
The second point is that Ukrainian estimates of the casualties they have been inflicting, which have been widely attacked by pro-Russian groups and dismissed by some as exaggerrated, look to be pretty close to reality. That is notable in the history of war, where exaggeration is common. So, when you see claims like this, it is best to take them very seriously.



















0 comments:
Post a Comment