A Blog by Jonathan Low


Dec 2, 2018

Tracking Everything: Can Blockchain Maps Replace GPS?

Yeah, it's worked so well in crytocurrencies, why wouldnt people trust it to assess their property, let alone national boundaries? JL

Shannon Mattern reports in The Atlantic:

Blockchain is backing a new mode of mapping. Crypto-cartographers hope to use it for spatial verification—confirming that things are where they say they are, when they claim to be there. (But) Problems arise when working with digital representations of physical assets such as land. Property boundaries, historically marked by degradable and movable things—stakes, streams, fence posts and handshakes—are often contested, and land areas are miscalculated because of  historical errors in measurement. There is more fluidity in physical boundaries than blockchain allows. Who knows would fare in a crypto-map?
Cryptocurrencies have had a rough year. Bitcoin has crashed more than 75 percent since its peak, and its competitors are faring no better. Even if the bubble has burst on non-fiat currency, the technology underlying those coins, the blockchain—which offers a way to record and validate transactions without a central authority, such as a bank or government—still excites many speculators outside finance.
In cities, for example, evangelists have promised an array of “blockchain urbanism” innovations. Some are outrageously ambitious: Crypto-entrepreneurs are migrating to marginal zones and developing regions where light regulation and low taxes permit them to build new states and cities in the blockchain’s own image. Others are more modest, applying the blockchain to urban inefficiencies in planning, zoning, building performance, and energy trading.
Blockchain is also backing a new mode of mapping. Crypto-cartographers hope to use it for spatial verification—confirming that things are where they say they are, when they claim to be there. How might this be useful? Well, you could know precisely when an Amazon delivery drone drops a package on your doorstep, at which point the charge would post to your account. No more unscrupulous delivery drivers, and no more contested charges for packages lost in transit. Or when opening a new bank account, you could virtually confirm your permanent address by physically being there during a particular verification period, rather than providing copies of your utility bills. You could also submit a photo of your flooded basement or smashed windshield to your insurance company, supplementing your claim with time- and location-verified documentation. Or, as you pass by your local family-owned coffee shop, the owner could “airdrop” some Bitcoin coupons to your phone, and you could stop by to cash in before the offer expires a half hour later.
These examples are certainly appealing. But the physical world might not be as easy to map as crypto-cartographers believe.

Money was blockchain’s first target, but in theory, any type of agreement that currently requires a middleman could be managed with blockchain technology instead—no lawyer, notary, bookie, or referee needed, as The New Yorker’s Nick Paumgarten puts it. A blockchain-based “smart contract” fulfills itself automatically, when its agreed-upon conditions have been met. The proof-of-location (PoL) protocol uses this approach for spatial verification.
Of course, we already have tools for geographic verification—Google Maps, Foursquare, OpenStreetMap, and the state-backed Global Positioning System (GPS) they rely on. But crypto-cartographers say we can’t always trust them. The commercial maps’ data are proprietary, and their plotted features sometimes fail to reflect rapid changes in real space. Crowdsourced tools such as OpenStreetMap are dogged by problems: insufficient funding, confusing usage policies, the failure to create incentives for contributors, and difficulty with accuracy.
And GPS, some critics say, is poorly suited for use in dense urban environments and indoors, drains cellphone batteries, and is centralized (a big downside for blockchain advocates). According to PoL upstart Foam, “Civil GPS is unencrypted, it has no proof-of-origin or authentication features, and despite dire warnings first raised in 2012, the system remains extremely susceptible to fraud, spoofing, jamming, and cyberattack.”
The cartographer and historian of science Bill Rankin finds some of these critiques a bit overstated. But they partly explain why Foam argues that “no reliable and trusted location verification service” exists, and there are “no established standards for embedded locations, physical addresses, or coordinates in smart contracts.” In the growing PoL space, each new platform comes with its own hardware infrastructure, protocols, economy, and obfuscatory language. Foam plans to create incentives for operators to build low-power, wide-area networks composed of radio beacons that can access the unlicensed radio spectrum. According to the CEO, Ryan John King, “Zone operators on the Foam network are in essence providing comparable work to Bitcoin miners.”
When four or more proximate beacons (Foam calls them “anchors”) form a “zone,” they can synchronize with one another to determine the position of objects. GPS works using the same general method, but it allows only for one-way communication; Foam’s PoL protocol allows users to send messages back to the system, which confirms the location via “verifiers” and saves it on the blockchain, King told me. What’s more, the Foam network is pretty hard to jam, and it requires less power than GPS does.
Foam’s protocol is open source. But cartographers have to purchase tokens that entitle them to contribute to it. Zone operators both stake and receive tokens as they perform their geolocative labors. The company hopes that this incentive system, which is not found in other volunteer crowdsourced projects, will help extend the network’s geographic coverage.
The protocol promotes other rewards, too. For a fee, anchors can also offer location services that use smart contracts to link a location on the blockchain to an address—a geohash—on the physical map. That’s how services including package tracking, address verification, and contract enforcement might work.
Location is meant to be commercialized: The platforms hope to “foster an ecosystem of applications built on top of a verified location standard,” as Foam puts it. The whole ecosystem, rather than some centralized authority, gets to determine what’s featured on the map. Contributors can stake their Foam tokens to create lists of points of interest (POIs), such as coffee shops with Wi-Fi, the best dog parks, urban landmarks, or government facilities. Other token holders can then vote on those lists; up-votes increase the value of the list and the value of the list creator’s tokens. Down-votes indicate that other token holders presume that a nominated POI will degrade the quality of a list.
Atop this infrastructure, Foam provides an interface, which it bills as “a cross between a Bloomberg trading terminal and Google Maps.” The dashboard allows users to interact with and act on all those smart contracts, facilitating an array of applications—from autonomous-vehicle tracking, to supply-chain management, to location-based games such as Pokémon Go. A Foam competitor, XYO Network, proposes that PoL could also help government agencies and police forces track regulated firearms, to make sure that they’re always in the hands of the agents authorized to handle them. I asked King whether or how they plan to discourage particular uses, such as surveillance and predatory marketing. He told me that “governance is built into the protocol” (unlike with GPS). Foam requires users to make a minimum deposit to participate; putting one’s own tokens up as collateral, King said, serves as an “anti-spam mechanism.” The voting procedure also provides checks and balances.
King explained that Foam’s is the only PoL project “providing full-stack location services,” including location and coding standards and the visualizer. “It’s important to start from scratch,” he said, to start a “whole new infrastructure,” to make location “holistic.”

What makes a “quality” list of places in the world? Foam claims that it focuses on “objective” spatial information, yet it seems to see spatial value in “economic or reputational terms.” That could lead users to stake their tokens to map readily verifiable, predictable features and high-quality neighborhoods and facilities (that is, those with a strong reputation for good schools, low crime, and high property values). Even so, users can also use their tokens to “signal” where location services are needed and to inspire growth in underserved areas. A bet on an up-and-coming area determines users’ “spatial-mining rewards”—the bounty doled out, in this case, for extending the map to underrepresented regions.
Signaling could become a means for crypto-real-estate speculation. That could have material effects—perhaps even gentrification and displacement—in real life. Yet King proposes that signaling could also be a “catalyst for projects for public good”—new green spaces or green development, for instance—and could enable cartographers to “attribute community value to places.”
Foam presents its crypto-mapping as an extension of mapping’s legacy, calling its users “contextualized successors to the work of cartographers throughout history that maintained geographic data about everything from topography to dense urban streets.” At the same time, the company sees itself as an economic and political engine, “granting control over the registries of POI to locally based markets and community forces.”
It’s hoping to inspire new urban services, local engagement, and increased efficiency. But not all “community forces” are positive; they also include NIMBY-ism and entrenched patterns of racism, classism, and other biases. Even social-entrepreneurial crypto-cartographers ostensibly committed to the public good could still plot and vote for points in accordance with their privileged (and, given that we’re talking about the blockchain, probably young male) perspectives and blind prejudices. Voting for points of interest hardly guarantees that they will serve the public well.
Foam also builds on the biases of its precursors, including GPS. As Rankin explains, the creators of GPS saw it as a utility that turned location into “a commodity available in much the same way as electricity or water.” For Rankin, that design has political implications: It “substitutes a locally available grid of geographic coordinates for other kinds of local knowledge,” such as folklore, vernacular histories, or habitual experience, he says. In so doing, GPS “encourages intervention without long-term commitment.” PoL could similarly incentivize location miners to find “collective value in the growth of the network,” as King proposed to me, framing growth and network effects as civic values. Still, crypto-cartographers could experience space through a dashboard, engaging with it via speculation, rather than with an abiding sense of local, on-the-ground responsibility.
What’s more, some things just don’t want to be “verified” or “divined.” Problems sometime arise when working with digital representations of physical assets such as land parcels. Property boundaries, historically marked by degradable and movable things—stakes and streams, fence posts and handshakes—are often contested, and land areas are sometimes miscalculated because of accumulated historical errors in measurement. Overall, there is far more fluidity in matters of physical boundaries and access than blockchain allows. Who knows how spaces such as informal infrastructures, indigenous terrains, and the leftover spaces that shelter the marginalized would fare in a crypto-map? Such spatial negotiations hardly seem to lend themselves to “objective” mapping and token-based votes. If the crypto-cartographers have their way, those communities could be down-voted into oblivion.


Ethan Willson said...

Looking great work dear, I really appreciated to you on this quality work. Nice post!! these tips may help me for future.Popcorn Time APK Download

Okseoabhinav said...

The information you are providing that is really good. Thank for making and spending your precious time for this useful information. Thanks again and keep it up. Top CA firm in India

Best IAS Coaching In India said...

This article will outline all the different strategies you should be aware of when it comes to soccer.

Top IAS Coaching in Mumbai


I appreciate your post, Please Keep posting with more information also see my post..

Best IAS Coaching in Delhi

Anuj Gold said...

You ever heard about Reecan the one and only Office Furniture Manufacturers which known for

its renovation of office and houses by furniture and designs. office are more modern and

spacious because of reecan is here.
Office Furniture Manufacturers

NextLevelTelemed said...

If you want to Buy Trimix Injections online from the trustable place. Don’t worry about that we are NextLevelTelMed where you can consult professional Doctor with free of cost to Buy Trimix Injection online For more details you can also visit out.
Website: - https://nextleveltelemed.com/
Contact: - Privacy@NextLevelTelemed.com

John Fei said...

Programming development is a fundamental piece of a business nowadays. This is a gigantic field of information that can in the end be changed into a completed item with the assistance of programming counseling administrations. Of late, organizations are getting increasingly intricate and require more mind boggling programming answers for assemble commercial center sites for instance appropriately. Recruiting a programmer probably won't be sufficient now, as few out of every odd organization's proprietor has a fair comprehension of what his business needs. Throughout the long term, the product software consulting industry developed so a lot, that it is currently ready to offer its types of assistance to different fields of business. Taking into account how much PCs attacked our lives it was inevitable for software engineers to turn into a piece of that industry also. As per Statista's report, the fame of such programming counseling administrations is just developing every day. Clearly, a particularly significant and complex field as programming development got one of the initial ones to offer programming specialist administrations. As a matter of first importance – programming development counseling is to assist an organization with utilizing its product as adequately as conceivable all together for the business to develop quickly. In this manner, there are numerous ways that programmer expert can help you in: client care, network safety occupations, technical support, and numerous others.

Unknown said...

Hello, i need some advise. Im student and in june i need to pass my dissertation, but i dont have enough time for preparing. I think i need help of phd thesis writing services. What you think?

MD Gaming said...

good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon.

Precisionrx Telemed - For Men's Health said...

Is this safe to buy trimix injection online? Trimix injections are available online but you should only buy it from a certified company that asks for a trimix prescription online, firstly because trimix injection is a prescribed medicine and cannot be sold without a prescription, secondly trimix injection cost is less when buying from an online site. Doctors who prescribe trimix injections always suggest a platform from where you can buy trimix injections online.

Zeke said...

Awesome website you have here but I was curious about if you knew of any discussion boards that cover the same topics discussed here? I’d really love to be a part of group where I can get feed-back from other knowledgeable individuals that share the same interest. If you have any suggestions, please let me know. Many thanks!

prathammetallics said...

Buy Sildenafil Troche 110mg
You can buy Sildenafil online from our notable website and it's considered to be a medicine that's prevalent within the kind of a tablet. This medicine is trademarked under Viagra’s name. consistent with an honest number of ED Clinic physicians, Sildenafil has been prescribed and also the respective person has to take it under the tongue and continually keep it there until it's absorbed by their salivary glands.

The Life Notes By Sg said...

Things to consider while finding the right life coach for you

Are you trying to reach a new level of success but wondering how to proceed? Life coaching training also referred to as Results Coaching, is the best solution. It is an incredibly powerful tool, which helps you achieve your most important goals. The best life coaches become guides and mentors who help you through life’s challenges and strengthen your mindset to achieve anything for which you made up your mind. Often people get overwhelmed and inquire how to find the best life coach near me.

Himesh Raja said...

If you feel like you have lost the zeal and intimacy of your sexual life then a reliable sexologist in Delhi is something that you certainly need. He has registered himself in the list of the top reputed sexologist. You have got it here! He is an honorable name in the industry of sexologist treatment and best sexologist in Delhi or top sexologist in Faridabad.

Himesh Raja said...

Looking for the best sexologist in Delhi? It's not that difficult. There are many avenues through which you can get help from a sexologist in Delhi. If you are looking for an experienced and skillful sexologist, you can visit the Center for Development of Sexuality and Health, located at New Delhi.

lindapaul said...

Are yo looking for Best Hospital in Kasaragod. Doctors Hospital are the leading multispecialty Hospital. We provide quality healthcare treatment at affordable price.

kckuldeep said...

1. We are going to discuss about best Sexologist in Delhi. You all know that Delhi is the capital of India and it is one of the rapidly growing cities of India.

ankit pal said...

Sexologist in Delhi is a well-known name in the list of best and famous sexologist in the city of Delhi. They are well-known and highly trained professionals to give you the right advice and treatment for various sexual problems including male sexual disorders, erectile dysfunction, premature , low libido, etc. They have a team of specialist under whom you can get the best solution for your problems. They have been practicing for a long time and have a huge experience in the field of sexual health. They have their own clinic where they treat their patients.

Saif Ali said...

Ver well. Keep sharing more. Please also read mine at Fun Livin' and let me know where I can improve.

SSUK said...

Thanks For Sharing. If you are looking for discount vouchers visit ShoppingSpout UK

igoal88 said...

This is a great post. I like this topic.This site has lots of advantage.I found many interesting things from this site. It helps me in many ways Thanks for posting this again.
ติดต่อสอบถาม igoal88

davidjames said...

Thanks for sharing this valuable article. Also, check Best CLAT Coaching In Delhi that provides high quality coaching with amazing teaching techniques.

davidjames said...

Thank you for sharing this amazing article with us. Here I am sharing a great resource on the best DU.LLB Coaching in Delhi. Please check out this article to know which coaching center is best and suitable for du.LLB preparation

Web One BLog said...

Find a sexologist Faridabad! Sexology is the scientific study of human sexual behavior, attractions, and function. We have a directory of sexologists in your local area. Find one today and book an appointment!. Here's a list of things to ask yourself when trying to find a good sexologist.
Sexologist in Faridabad

eddielydon said...

Thank you very much for this great post. fresh steve jacket

Jobi Johnson said...

I read this article. I think You put a lot of effort to create this article. I appreciate your work. Ryan Gosling The Gray Man Jacket

Nelly Barrow said...

We are accustomed to recruiting individuals to translate, yet is it worth doing it now? Obviously, in the event that you want to translate and legally approve a few reports, indeed, yet in different cases you can manage without them. In the event that you simply translate texts, then, at that point, there is Google translator and comparative free assets. What's more, in the event that you want to translate the video, contact Vidby https://vidby.com/. They will make a speedy interpretation and dubbing of the video in any language and without utilizing human assets, everything happens naturally, utilizing algorithms.

Amar Singh said...

"Thank you for sharing this useful information, I will regularly follow your blog. Excellent post! Hypertherm Consumables Supplier
Hypertherm consumables are a critical part of the cutting process, and we offer a variety of options to suit your specific application needs. Hypertherm consumables is a great option. Their products are backed by a strong warranty and customer support team, so you can be confident in your purchase.Hypertherm's consumables are designed to deliver consistent performance and long-term reliability. If you're looking for a high-quality plasma cutter consumable, Hypertherm is a great option."

Amar Singh said...

"Thank you for sharing this useful information, I will regularly follow your blog. Excellent post!Hypertherm consumables are a critical part of the cutting process, and we offer a variety of options to suit your specific application needs. Hypertherm consumables is a great option. Hypertherm Consumables Supplier
Their products are backed by a strong warranty and customer support team, so you can be confident in your purchase.Hypertherm's consumables are designed to deliver consistent performance and long-term reliability. If you're looking for a high-quality plasma cutter consumable, Hypertherm is a great option."

Post a Comment