A Blog by Jonathan Low

 

Nov 6, 2019

Advertisers Demand Data Proving Value As They Sour On Social Media Influencers

Engagement rates are down, audits suggest fraudulently inflating followers is rampant and consumer surveys report lessening purchase decision influence. JL


Suzanne Kapner and Sharon Terlep report in the Wall Street Journal:

With no way to measure sales or verify how many people see the ads, companies that paved the way for the influencer economy are questioning if it’s worth it. Influencers have strained ties with advertisers by inflating the number of their followers, sometimes buying fake ones by the thousands. They also have damaged their credibility with followers by promoting products they don’t use. Accurately tracking the effectiveness of influencer advertising is difficult. Their influence is waning. Engagement rates are down. An analytics firm, investigated 1.84 million Instagram accounts and found more than half used fraud to inflate the number of followers.
Ipsy, an online cosmetic brand, was a pioneer in paying social-media stars hefty fees to promote its eye shadow and lip gloss in Instagram posts and YouTube videos.
Now, the brand is leading the way again, this time by pulling back.
Companies will funnel billions of dollars this year to the online personalities, known as influencers, who pitch their products on social media. Yet with no way to measure sales or verify how many people even see the ads, the companies that paved the way for the influencer economy—mostly early adopters like Ipsy—are questioning if it’s worth it.
What began as friends and family sharing their favorite products has become a lucrative advertising industry of celebrity endorsers, influencers and meme creators. Such paid endorsements, known as sponsored content, are the online equivalent of a 30-second TV spot. Big-name stars can command $100,000 or more for a single YouTube video or Instagram photo.

Influencer Inflation

But a whiff of deceit now taints the influencer marketplace. Influencers have strained ties with advertisers by inflating the number of their followers, sometimes buying fake ones by the thousands. They also have damaged their credibility with real-life followers by promoting products they don’t use.
“All these paid posts make you question whether influencers are genuine or just doing it for the money,” said JaLynn Evans, a 19-year-old student at Virginia Commonwealth University.
The loss of trust undermines the power of influencers, according to Marcelo Camberos, Ipsy’s chief executive. “Have they peaked? I don’t know,” he said. These days, the firm is recruiting its own customers to post products—for free. Accurately tracking the effectiveness of influencer advertising is difficult. By one measure, their influence is waning. Engagement rates, which measure the number of “likes” a post generates as a percent of a person’s followers, are down this year, compared with the same period last year, according to InfluencerDB, which makes tools to help brands manage influencer campaigns.
“Consumers can see if someone honestly cares about a product or whether they are just trying to push it,” said Anders Ankarlid, chief executive of online stationery retailer A Good Company. “The bubble is starting to burst.”
Advertisers can’t ignore social media. Instagram alone has more than 1 billion monthly users. Mediakix, an influencer marketing agency, estimates companies will spend between $4.1 billion and $8.2 billion globally in 2019 on influencers. That is up from $500 million in 2015, but still a fraction of the $624.2 billion companies will spend globally this year on advertising, according to an estimate by media buying agency Zenith.
Walmart Inc. this year began adding influencer posts to its website to promote products such as Sofia Jeans by Sofia Vergara and a home collection by blogger Liz Marie. Last year, Unilever PLC warned that fraud undercut the power of influencers. Yet in June, its investment arm agreed to buy a stake in a software company that helps brands oversee influencer campaigns.
Despite questions about declining influence, the money paid Influencers keeps climbing—roughly 50% a year since 2017, according to Mediakix, which helps match brands with influencers. Prices per Instagram post range from $200 for an influencer with as few as 10,000 followers to more than $500,000 for celebrities with millions of followers, according to Mediakix.
A lawsuit this month hinted at the sums paid the biggest celebrity influencers. The singer Ariana Grande sued Forever 21 Inc. for allegedly stealing her likeness after she rejected an endorsement deal with the clothing retailer.
Ms. Grande, who has 165 million Instagram followers, accused the company of hiring a look-alike model for its Instagram posts and website. The model wore a hairstyle and clothing similar to what the pop star wore in her “7 rings” music video, which has more than half a billion YouTube views.
“The market value for even a single Instagram post by Ms. Grande is well into the six figures,” said the lawsuit, which seeks at least $10 million in damages. Forever 21, in a statement, disputed the allegations.
Akash Mehta, an influencer with 293,000 Instagram followers, has been paid by such well-known brands as Volvic water and Swiss watchmaker Ulysse Nardin SA. He was recently offered five times his $2,000 asking price for a single post by another brand. The big offer, he said, “was a turning point for me. It made me realize that influencer marketing has gone wrong.”
Mr. Mehta said he accepted the payment, but he didn’t believe he could deliver five times the value of what he usually charges.
Some established brands also see trouble. Kellogg Co. , which paid the endurance athlete and Special K fan Sophie Radcliffe to post about her love of the cereal, said standing out from the crowd has gotten tough. “Consumers are wising up to how influencers work,” said Joseph Harper, Kellogg’s e-commerce marketing manager for Western Europe.
Sensing the shift, some companies are rethinking how they use influencers. Banana Republic, which has used such high-profile influencers as Olivia Palermo, a socialite with 6.2 million Instagram followers, is also tapping its own customers. The Gap Inc. -owned clothing chain has real-life shoppers pose in their favorite Banana Republic outfits on Instagram, in exchange for $150 gift cards.
Cassie Fisher, 21, was one recruit who said she had soured on influencers with no connection to the products they promote. What sets her apart from influencer phonies is that she was already buying most of her clothes at Banana Republic when the brand reached out to her, she said.
“My friends and I are sick of being sold things all the time,” said Ms. Fisher, a student at University of South Florida with 1,342 Instagram followers. “When you scroll through your Instagram feed, it’s one sponsored post after another.”
Mr. Mehta, the influencer, also worked as a digital media manager for Christian Dior SE and Estée Lauder Cos. overseeing their influencer-marketing programs. He said companies don’t always know what they are buying.
“When you pay for a billboard, you know roughly how many people will see it,” said Mr. Mehta, 25. “With Instagram you have no idea. Followers can be bought.”
A Good Company, the online retailer, worked with 4,000 influencers to promote its eco-friendly stationery and other office supplies. It paid them cash or gift cards for their social-media posts.
The company, which didn’t get its expected sales boost, sent an anonymous survey to their influencers, asking if they had ever paid for followers, likes or comments. Nearly two-thirds of respondents said yes, Mr. Ankarlid, the CEO, said.
HypeAuditor, an analytics firm, investigated 1.84 million Instagram accounts and found more than half used fraud to inflate the number of followers.
Some influencers had large numbers of followers who weren’t real people, meaning the accounts had been bought or were inactive, according to Anna Komok, HypeAuditor’s marketing manager. Clues include large numbers of followers outside the influencer’s home country.
The scams cost little. Enterprises known as click farms employ people to inflate online traffic. They sell 1,000 bogus YouTube followers for as little as $49. On Facebook, the same number of followers costs $34, and on Instagram they cost $16, according to Masarah Paquet-Clouston, a researcher at cybersecurity firm GoSecure, who collaborated with others to seek prices.
Facebook and Instagram, which is owned by Facebook Inc., have policies against such deceptions, a company spokesperson said. The company said Instagram has an initiative to remove phony likes, follows and comments from accounts that use third-party apps to boost popularity. YouTube also prohibits such deceptions.
Influencer deception will cost advertisers $1.3 billion this year, estimated Roberto Cavazos, a statistics professor at the University of Baltimore.
TV, radio, magazine and newspaper advertising are based on standardized, audited third-party measures, including those from Nielsen Holdings PLC.
Some influencers mislead followers by failing to disclose when they are paid to post about products or services, as stipulated by Federal Trade Commission guidelines.
Tom Le Bree said when he co-founded online retailer Beautonomy in 2018, “We thought influencers would be a silver bullet and bring all the traffic we needed.”
Beautonomy worked with influencers with about 100,000 followers on Instagram and other social media. The influencers created their own Beautonomy makeup palettes and promoted products in posts. Beautonomy, which is co-owned by beauty company Coty Inc., agreed to give the influencers a percentage of sales. But they didn’t generate enough sales to justify the program.
The company instead turned to buying ads on Facebook and elsewhere, Mr. LeBree said.
Advertising executive James Cole said he worked on dozens of social media campaigns with influencers without any measurable return. He quit trying.
Instead, Mr. Cole founded H Hub, which operates more like a traditional ad agency. It connects photographers, videographers and other content creators with brands, including Yelp Inc. Rather than paying influencers, brands acquire content from H Hub and post it themselves.
“When Instagram started, it was a place you looked at images posted by your friends or other people you trusted,” he said. “Brands ruined it by injecting their own messages. Consumers are wising up to the fact that just because an influencer posts about a product doesn’t mean they actually like it.”
Jewelry retailer Alexis Bittar has moved away from influencers. The company now prefers creating its own social media content. Recent posts include photos of the 1968 Alexis Bittar-branded Volkswagen bus the company shows off at such events as Art Basel in Miami and the Coachella music festival in California.
“We scaled back paying for posts,” said Matteo Del Vecchio, chief executive of Alexis Bittar’s parent company, Deconic, which is owned by Brooks Brothers. “It’s difficult to quantify how that translates into sales.”
Even with high-price offers, some influencers are having second thoughts.
Amber Atherton caught the attention of advertisers after she starred in the British reality TV show “Made in Chelsea.” Then she experienced the influencer’s dilemma. “Brands were offering to pay me $5,000 for a single post,” she said, “even though they weren’t relevant to my followers.” She turned down products she wouldn’t use, she said.
Ms. Atherton later founded Zyper, a software company that has helped Banana Republic and other companies find customers to enlist as influencers.
When Ipsy got its start in 2011, its strategy of using influencers instead of traditional advertising was unconventional. Founder Michelle Phan was also an influencer, giving makeup advice on YouTube. By 2017, she had 10 million followers. That year, she left Ipsy and stopped posting on YouTube.
“Who I was on camera and who I was in real life began to feel like strangers,” Ms. Phan said, in a YouTube video to explain her exit.

62 comments:

Sam Jonsib said...

Con el fin de evitar todos los problemas de próstata, le recomiendo que pruebe aquí este sitio https://espanolfarmacia.net/comprar-proscar-finasteride/ , donde puede encontrar una solución a este problema, estoy seguro de que definitivamente estará satisfecho

Kevin Nelson said...

Do you ever buy facebook page likes? We start processing your order as soon as you completed the purchase. Your order is completed within the estimated delivery time that we show on the service's page.

Laura Bush said...

For a long time me & my friend were searching for informative blogs, but now I am in the right place guys, you have made a room in my heart. Instagram Followers Panel

promotemyprofile said...

Hi there, I read your blogs on a regular basis. Your humoristic style is witty, keep it up! Thank You for Providing Such a Unique and valuable information, If you are looking for the best Get Instagram Followers & Likes,then visit promotemyprofile. I enjoyed this blog post.

Kevin Nelson said...

The more time you spend on the app keeping your followers engaged, the more Instagram will favor you. If you want to know tips and tricks to gain more likes on Instagram, check out SGuru

saivenkat said...

Well Said, you have furnished the right information that will be useful to anyone at all time. Thanks for sharing your Ideas.
Purchase Order

Python Training Expert said...

Data Science Training Course- Start upskilling at INR 10,000.Further More Details about Data Science Training Institute in Delhi So Contact Here-+91-9310332343 Or Visit Website- http://www.pythontrainingdelhi.com/python-with-data-science.html

Famoid said...

really a great post thanks for sharing such informative content it is also looking such great content about social media networks and social media marketing it is difficult to search this type content that will give you exact information if someone wishes to write for us, we are glad to welcome you buy Instagram followers uk

Harry said...

now days people knowing the power of social media and other public platform that's why people prefer to buy real tiktok followers Australia to become famous on social media

smmking said...

Your blog is really impressive, you included much knowledge for us. It genuinely had good content. Thanks for sharing this.
buy instagram followers India

Christina Porter said...

Without a proper presence in online directories, your business may fail to reach a potential customer who could travel just minutes from their home to get what they need from your company. Umdum Directory

smmpanel said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Harry said...

really a great post thanks for sharing this cheap instagram followers Australia

Unknown said...

After reading your article I was amazed. I know that you explain it very well. And I hope that other readers will also experience how I feel after reading your article. Purchase Orders

SMM HEART said...

Such a lovely collection which you have shared here. I liked your way to express your views in this article. Thank you for sharing this blog with us. prime smm panel

Unknown said...

I generally check this kind of article and I found your article which is related to my interest. Genuinely it is good and instructive information. Thankful to you for sharing an article like this.SMM Panel for Premium Accounts

Breet Pink said...

What is the best SMM panel for YouTube?
#1 - Cheapest and Best SMM Panel. ...
#2 - Peakerr.com- Best SMM Panel. ...
#3 - tikviralme.com - Buy Tiktok Followers, Likes and Views. ...
#4 World Largest Smm Panel. ...
#5 Zenithsmm.com - #1 SMM Panel. ...
#6 Cheap smm panel, best prices for resellers. ...
#7 SmmAhead - Worldwide Quality SMM Service Provider Panel.

abanic 2013 servicios S.L said...

The information you've provided is useful because it provides a wealth of knowledge that will be highly beneficial to me. Thank you for sharing that. Keep up the good work. best smm panel

justsocialpanel said...

I prefer high-quality content, which I discovered in your article. The information you've provided is useful and important to us. Continue to post articles like these. Thank you very much. Smm services provider

yoyomedia said...

I am truly impressed by the details which you have provided regardingcheap smm panel india. It is an interesting article for me as well as for others. Thanks for sharing such articles here.

Social Media Marketing said...

You've created an excellent essay. Your essay gave me some unique and useful information. Thank you for bringing this article to our attention. smm reseller panel    

Breet Pink said...

What is the benefit of having a virtual office?
Not only do virtual offices allow for no commute time, low to no technology costs and lower overhead costs (with no lease to pay), having remote workers also cuts down on commute time, increases productivity, and produces a lower turnover rate.
More details

Glen Jacobs said...

This is really a good source of information, I will often follow it to know more information and expand my knowledge, I think everyone should know it, thanks Best Best SMM panel for Instagram service provider

Breet Pink said...

Why do shops use EPOS and EFT?
Every good retailer should use an EPOS (Electronic Point Of Sale) system, as it is an indispensable tool for businesses. ... They process sales transactions electronically by itemising and summarising sales and accurately receiving and recording payments.

Social Media Marketplace said...

It's really a great and helpful bit of data that you have shared here. I'm glad that you just imparted this accommodating data to us. Kindly share these types knowledge with us. Much thanks to you for sharing it. Buy Instagram Followers

Dig Dug Dig said...

I admire this article for the well-researched content and excellent wording. I got so involved in this material that I couldn’t stop reading. I am impressed with your work and skill. Thank you so much. Read more info about Social Network Site India

skigit said...

A very delightful article that you have shared here. Your blog is a valuable and engaging article for us, and also I will share it with my companions who need this info. Thankful to you for sharing an article like this. Earned Media

monkoffinance said...

Extremely useful information which you have shared here about social media reseller panel This is a great way to enhance knowledge for us, and also helpful for us. Thankful to you for sharing an article like this.

monkoffinance said...

This is a good post. Thanks for sharing with us, Excellent work and I appreciate your work. Buy SMM panel Netflix at cheap price.

Unknown said...

to be honest your post is informative and very helpful. After i saw your post and it help me a lot. Thanks for share your kind information. SMM Panel Reseller.

Unknown said...

I am truly impressed by the details which you have provided regarding best smm panel It is an interesting article for me as well as for others. Thanks for sharing such articles here.

Conall Potter said...

It is truly well-researched content and has excellent wording. I got so engaged in this material that I couldn’t wait to read it. I am impressed with your work and skill SMM Panel Provider

Conall Potter said...

Wow, What an Excellent post. I really found this to be too much information about smm panel usa. It is what i was searching for.I would like to suggest you that please keep sharing such type of info.Thanks

Husnain said...

top SMM Panel and 100% High Quality for all social networks. Get the best Instagram panel today, Instagram Reseller Panel Buy Instagram Followers Worldwide, Buy Instagram Female Followers, Buy Instagram Real Profile Followers, Buy Instagram Photo Likes and Views, Buy Instagram Save and Reach, Buy Instagram Auto Post Likes.

Breet Pink said...

What is an IT solutions provider?
S. An umbrella term for an organization that offers any combination of computer hardware, software and consulting. In the past, a solutions provider often built custom hardware and developed custom applications for its customers. Today, a solutions provider may use only packaged products. Site

Elijah said...

I have bookmarked your page that explains it very well, I am excited to see more of it. I am glad that I came to see this, I really loved it. Thank you for sharing it. SMM Service Provider

William said...

Wonderful Message for all which you have shared here. This is very informative for those who need this. In the future share this type of informative article here with us. buy instagram likes paytm

Breet Pink said...

Research Chemicals is a reliable online shopping site that provides high-quality research chemicals at affordable prices. We are proud to offer research chemicals from professional sellers around the world.
Learn More

Mark D said...

Such a great post thanks for sharing this important information I really appreciate you and also suggest to my friends must visit your blog you can also buy real Instagram followers uk

Salena Barly said...

smm captain is a legit site to get social media services at an affordable price visit now and buy instagram followers cheap uk cheap with super fast delivery and money-back guarantee.

buy tiktok followers said...

Buy real and active Instagram followers, likes, views, comments and tiktok followers, likes, views from us at cheap rates; we are canada based company satisfying hundreds of customers daily.CLICK HERE FOR MORE INFORMATION.

followergain said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
followergain said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
followergain said...

Buy real and active Instagram followers, likes, views, comments and tiktok followers, likes, views from us at cheap rates; we are UK based company satisfying hundreds of customers daily.click here for more information this link attached
https://followerssales444893061.wordpress.com/2022/02/23/the-oddest-services-for-dealing-with-instagram-are-listed-below

social media followers said...

Buy High-quality Instagram followers likes and views in the uk, get instant followers and likes at an affordable price with 24/7 support from buy Instagram followers uk

https://followerssales444893061.wordpress.com/2022/02/23/the-oddest-services-for-dealing-with-instagram-are-listed-below

SMMTube said...

Extremely useful information which you have shared here about smm panel This is a great way to enhance knowledge for us, and also beneficial for us. Thank you for sharing an article like this.

cheapest tiktok likes
<a href="https://smmtube.pro/buy-spotify-plays>cheapest spotify plays</a>

mahi said...

https://teletype.in/@mahna/85sIZkcgmWF

buy instagram followers canada said...

Pretty good post.Really a great post thanks for sharing this good information. buy tiktok followers

buy instagram followers said...

Thanks for sharing such an interesting post.
buy instagram views

Tech & DM said...

Thank you so much for sharing the information.
If you want to become viral and famous on Instagram, get the services of Social Follower UK and become a viral on Social platforms.
Social Followers takes the responsibility for getting you famous by letting you buy Instagram likes uk, followers, comments, and more.

Tech & DM said...

I’ve been surfing the web for more than 3 hours today, yet I never found any stunning article like yours. It’s alluringly worth it for me.
Thanks for sharing such nice information.
Social Followers takes the responsibility for getting you famous by letting you buy Instagram likes uk, followers, comments, and more.

followerssales said...

Pretty good post.Really a great post thanks for sharing this good information.
https://eurasiannews.net/why-your-advertising-on-tiktok-social-networks-does-not-work

topsmm said...

very interesting points.Thanks for thin info here. tik tok smm panel

Alia parker said...

When choosing a Sim card for travel, make sure to select one that offers the best coverage in your destination. Some carriers offer more widespread coverage than others, so it's worth checking before you travel.

SOCIAL MEDIA SERVICES said...

We are here and prepared to assist you with all of your SMM needs. Users or clients looking for Inexpensive SMM services or those having SMM orders are more than welcome to use our cheapest smm panel.

gnevotech said...

You're amazing since the article you've written is both engaging and informative. Thank you for sharing that. Keep up the good work. Social Media Marketing Solutions

Robert said...

A top site for auto aficionados, is toyota paint protection film takes visitors on an exciting adventure through the world of automobiles. This digital hub skillfully combines knowledge and enthusiasm.

Post a Comment