A Blog by Jonathan Low

 

Nov 12, 2020

With Meteoric Rise In Deaths, Covid Modelers Say Talk Of Waves Is Misleading

Healthcare modelers do not call them waves because there were never troughs: the virus incidence flattened a bit but never dipped below the initial highs, signalling that it was never brought under control. JL

Elizabeth Cooney reports in Stat:

The meteoric rise in U.S. Covid-19 cases and death is not another wave. The consensus among major Covid-19 modelers is that we could see 20,000 to 25,000 deaths in the next two weeks, and 160,000 more by Feb. 1. Calling this a second or third wave is incorrect because there was never a significant trough before cases began mounting again. The outbreak that slammed New York in the spring — as well as cities like Boston, New Orleans, and Detroit — was never brought under control, and instead it’s been allowed to keep building.

The numbers have become both horrifying and numbing — and there is no end in sight.

The consensus among major Covid-19 modelers is that we could see 20,000 to 25,000 deaths in just the next two weeks, and 160,000 more by Feb. 1. That would be a frightening acceleration as winter approaches.

The experts and their models also agree on the familiar tools at hand that can bend the curve: universal mask-wearing and social distancing. Even so, they say it’s too late for us to head off the surge ahead, as many Asian countries have been able to do.


“We may have passed the point of no return in terms of getting it to a place like levels we’re seeing in China right now,” said Nicholas Reich, a University of Massachusetts, Amherst, biostatistician whose team compares different Covid-19 models.

The meteoric rise in U.S. Covid-19 cases and death is not another wave. 


Experts modeling the coronavirus pandemic may differ on details, but they agree that calling this a second or third wave is incorrect because there was never a significant trough before cases began mounting again. 

The outbreak that slammed New York in the spring — as well as cities like Boston, New Orleans, and Detroit — was never brought under control, and instead it’s been allowed to keep building. 

Covid tracker screen cap 11/12/20
The STAT Covid-19 Tracker bears out what modelers say: There have not been significant troughs before cases have risen again.STAT

“I don’t think the United States ever had multiple waves,” said Alessandro Vespignani, professor of physics, computer science, and health science at Northeastern University in Boston who models the pandemic’s impact. “We are leading the same wave that is moving across the country.”

This is not 1918. Then, graphs show, there was a terrifying spike in influenza deaths followed by a flat line, when the epidemic almost went dormant in the summer before a monstrous second wave in the fall. Historical hindsight will have to tell what shape the Covid-19 story will ultimately take, but maybe future modelers will call them humps, Reich offered. Broadly speaking, the U.S. is heading toward a third hump while Europe is near its second. 

There’s a worrying parallel there, Reich said. “It’s just that humans are tiring of having to be so vigilant and it’s really exhausting — emotionally exhausting and socially exhausting.” 

The world’s health is in a very bad place, heading into winter in the Northern Hemisphere with Covid-19 cases, deaths, and hospitalizations all tallying new highs. That’s even before an expected spurt in all three metrics caused by colder weather and drier air, people spending much more time indoors, and overall weariness of lives disrupted by pandemic precautions — all of which make us more vulnerable to viruses. 

Trevor Bedford, a computational biologist at the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Institute in Seattle, reminded people taking comfort from an apparently lower death rate than earlier in the pandemic that deaths lag infections by about three weeks. “I expect the US to be reporting over 2000 deaths per day in 3 weeks time,” he tweeted Wednesday. That would be more than double the current numbers.

The U.S. as a whole has seen regional curves go up, dip, climb even higher, dip a bit less, and then ascend still higher to set new records nearly every day and every week. The geography of the pandemic is uneven, with ripples and bursts in the Sun Belt over the summer and infections jumping in the Midwest and Mountain states in the fall. But states in the Northeast that nearly buckled beneath the spring surge have no safe harbor from the continuing crisis. Cases and deaths have been ticking upward for weeks, as regular in their climb as a metronome.

Modelers make forecasts four weeks out, predicting cases and deaths. Separate models can be aggregated to yield an overall estimate of cases and deaths; some but not all include hospitalizations. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention posts its ensemble forecasts, generated by Reich’s group at UMass from 36 independent models, for the country as a whole and for individual states. Models make assumptions about social distancing measures changing in the future or staying the same. 

Projections go farther than forecasts, but even they stretch only to Feb. 1, when warmer parts of the country might see crocus shoots poking through the soil in early signs of spring while winter is far from over in many states.

The model from the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation projects 399,162 total deaths in the U.S. by Feb. 1, based on current conditions. If mask wearing became universal, defined as worn by 95% of the population, deaths would fall to 337,669, the model says. But if mandates for social distancing were eased, the death toll would rise to 513,657.

February might be the earliest that the first vaccines become widely available, should they win approval. That means we are left with the tools and knowledge currently at hand to control spread this winter: pulling up our masks, tamping down numbers of people we gather with indoors (with optimal ventilation), getting our flu shots, and resisting the undertow of pandemic fatigue.

“The projections for this winter, unfortunately, they’re going to hold unless we change our behavior. The vaccine is not going to help us,” said Ali Mokdad, professor of health metrics sciences at IHME. “All we have between now and the vaccine deployment is wearing a mask, keeping a safe distance. I would like to remind everybody in the U.S. we’re not out of the woods yet.”

Mokdad calls for a national strategy that would set data standards and improve surveillance of cases and deaths so a coordinated response could be set into motion. 

Northeastern’s Vespignani also said the lack of a national strategy handicaps state efforts to fight the pandemic, especially when prompt reactions to rising cases can make a difference. Models that show climbing case counts, for example, should spur immediate measures before hospitals and their ICUs fill to overflowing two weeks later.

Coherent messaging would help, particularly in a time of White House transition. Any approved, successful vaccine will be a game changer, Vespignani said, but not anytime soon, so telling people what works now will be essential. “We need to enforce the use of masks and we need to have people act responsibly. We need to have a lot of testing and tracing in place,” he said. “And then the most important thing is that we don’t want to catch up with the epidemic. We want to anticipate it.” 

Lockdowns are not on Vespignani’s list. “It would be very depressing. It would mean that we didn’t learn anything in the first nine months of the epidemic.”

One lesson from the spring: Researchers who mined mobile phone data to identify the indoor public places most responsible for the spread of Covid-19 say that sharply limiting the occupancy of these locales — chiefly restaurants, gyms, cafes, hotels, and houses of worship — could help control the pandemic without resorting to lockdowns.

Modelers and policymakers alike struggle to find the sweet spot of doing just enough to keep the pandemic under control while keeping schools open, allowing people to work, and letting them go grocery shopping.

“One of the reasons that Covid-19 is so hard to predict is that the power to change the trajectory is within us,” Reich of UMass said. “If we all of a sudden decided to just be really careful about this for a sustained period of time, it would become under control — or at least become more under control.

“It is the societal challenge of our times.”

15 comments:

Unknown said...

My Name is Dr Olu Herbal Remedy is 100% guarantee for Penis Enlargement you can Contact Me via Whataspp +2348140654426 For Best natural male enhancement Product with 100% guaranteed results. I prepare top Herbal selling male enhancement product with herbal formula and no side-effects . Contact Me Via Email : Drolusolutionhome@gmail.com Via WhatsApp: +2348140654426



































My Name is Dr Olu Herbal Remedy is 100% guarantee for Penis Enlargement you can Contact Me via Whataspp +2348140654426 For Best natural male enhancement Product with 100% guaranteed results. I prepare top Herbal selling male enhancement product with herbal formula and no side-effects . Contact Me Via Email : Drolusolutionhome@gmail.com Via WhatsApp: +2348140654426

John Brown said...

I have been going toward the issue of Hp 49 Service Error for an impossibly broadened length. For that I appeared at Hp keep up. Experience was palatable and PC is obviously running speedier now. Moreover web coalition is better.. Dan was a decent tech and he was strikingly critical. I will endorse to a mate. I'm glad Dan called me since I had dismissed we had your affiliation.

Hp Error 49.4c02

MS Dave said...

Its always good to have tips on good blog posting. As I just started posting comments for blog and faced a lot of rejections.Check out the way to fix Hp Printer Printhead Error 0xc19a0020.

MS Dave said...

Some interesting and well researched information on cameras. I'll put a link to this site on my blog. Thank you!Check out the way to fix IP Address in Mac.

IT services said...

You made some valid statements .I did a little research on the point and found that a great many people concur with your blog. Much appreciated.


Also, read a blog by Robin
Business Intelligence Services

IT services said...

I think the error is due to a virus and disabling the firewall in that case will not be an intelligent thing to do.
Also, read blog by Methu
Error Code 0xc0000185

james thomas said...

Everything you want to know about the Cash app support number

The money application does not have a cash app support number, which customers can contact to contact a service representative for the money request. However, if you search Google for "Cash Support" and find a phone number that will help you communicate with your Cash app, it's a scam. However, the only real phone number is the helpline. However, you can visit our customer support website.

james thomas said...

Chime app customer service: immediate source of solution:

If you are searching for an immediate source of solution service for your chime app account then talk to the Chime Customer Service professional. They are highly competent and offer the service as per the exact needs. It refers to their tendency of taking a look at the cause deeply to analyze the kind of service to be provided to their customers.

nova smith said...




How To Check Cash App Balance To Avoid Payment Failure Problems?
If you are getting worried due to not able to handle payment failure problems on your Cash App account, you should simply take help from the Cash App support executives. Here, they will make you acquainted with the right mode of understanding How To Check Cash App Balance and get the suitable solutions.

miler7 said...

What Are The Right Ways To Activate Cash App Card Easily?
Are you one of those who have applied for a Cash App card?If you are also looking to Activate Cash App Card, you can either do it either automatically or manually.Besides, if you are having any difficulties while doing the same,you can easily get in touch with the professionals who are available at your doorstep. https://www.cash-app-helps.com/blog/how-to-activate-cash-app-card/

Will Johnson said...

Amazing blog ever come across on the internet. It really shows your immense knowledge and research on this topic. Please keep sharing.
Facebook Marketplace Help

Will Johnson said...

Having read your post, I am compelled to give thumps up to your post. Want to get right solution. How to get Facebook Marketplace Customer Service

jhonsaddy96 said...

Get in touch with experts for help on the Sutton bank cash app issue

Want to know about Sutton bank cash app? If yes then you must seek cash app help. Freely dial the helpline number to ask your queries from the Sutton customer support team. With this, users will help in fixing all kinds of glitches without any delay.
https://www.7qasearch.net/blog/how-can-i-contact-sutton-bank-for-cash-app/

networker said...

Thanks for sharing this valuable information about Professional Social Media Networks USA . I have gone through your blogs and got meaningful information.

Post a Comment